The Ghost of Gloves Past: Anthony Volpe and the Yankees' Defensive Dilemma
Published on: August 17, 2025
The crack of the bat. The roar of the crowd. The… errant throw sailing into the dugout? That’s been the too-familiar soundtrack to Anthony Volpe’s 2025 season, a dissonant melody jarring the ears of Yankees faithful and leaving the pinstriped brass with a thorny dilemma. Today, for the first time in 46 games, the young shortstop finds himself out of the starting lineup, replaced by Jose Caballero. This isn't a scheduled rest day; it’s a desperate attempt to staunch the bleeding from a defensive wound that’s festered all season.
Two years ago, Volpe burst onto the scene, a whirlwind of leather and grit, flashing a defensive prowess that earned him a Gold Glove in his rookie campaign. He was the defensive anchor of a team desperately searching for stability, a beacon of hope amidst a sputtering offense. His bat lagged, sure, his .283 OBP a glaring weakness in an otherwise promising profile. But the glove, oh that glove. It was enough, we were told. It was the bedrock upon which a future star would be built. He was the heir apparent to the legacy of Jeter, the next great Yankee shortstop.
Fast forward to the present, and the narrative has taken a decidedly darker turn. Volpe’s glove, once his saving grace, has become his albatross. The errors have piled up like dirty laundry, 16 so far this season, trailing only Cincinnati’s Elly De La Cruz in the dubious race for most miscues. He’s held, or shared, the inglorious title of league leader in errors multiple times this summer, each bobble, each misplayed grounder, a dagger in the heart of the Yankees’ playoff aspirations.
And these aren’t just harmless flubs, little hiccups in an otherwise solid performance. These errors have come at crucial junctures, costing the Yankees close games and fueling the growing chorus of discontent from fans and analysts alike. The whispers have turned to shouts, questioning Manager Aaron Boone’s unwavering loyalty to the struggling shortstop. Boone, ever the optimist, continues to publicly praise Volpe’s talent and work ethic, but even his pronouncements are starting to ring hollow in the face of mounting evidence. How long can he justify sticking with a player whose defensive liabilities are actively sabotaging the team’s chances?
The advanced metrics only serve to confirm what our eyes have been telling us all along. Volpe’s Fielding Run Value has plummeted from a respectable +8 in 2024 to a dismal -6 this season. Outs Above Average, another key defensive indicator, tells a similar story: a precipitous drop from +13 to -8. He's struggling on balls hit to his left, to his right, even those seemingly easy plays right in front of him. The once-elite defender is now a defensive black hole, sucking the life out of the infield and contributing to the Yankees’ inconsistent performance.
The trade deadline offered a glimmer of hope, a chance for the Yankees to address their glaring shortstop problem. But instead of acquiring a proven veteran, they swung a curious mid-game deal with Tampa Bay for Jose Caballero. The timing was bizarre, the move itself puzzling. Caballero, while a serviceable player, wasn't exactly a game-changer. He was, at best, a stopgap, a temporary solution to a long-term problem. And even he hasn't been immune to the defensive woes that seem to plague the Yankees infield, committing a costly error in the outfield that contributed to a recent loss against the Marlins.
Ironically, in that very same game, Volpe provided a fleeting reminder of his potential, launching a late-inning home run that briefly gave the Yankees the lead. But the lead, like so many others this season, evaporated, snatched away by the very defensive deficiencies that Volpe embodies. This has been the story of his 2025 season: flashes of brilliance interspersed with frustratingly frequent lapses in judgment and execution.
The decision to bench Volpe today is more than just a routine rest day. It’s a tacit acknowledgment that the Yankees are at a crossroads. With the postseason race tightening, every out is magnified, every error amplified. The margin for error is shrinking, and Volpe’s defensive struggles have become too costly to ignore. His arm, while still registering a respectable 82 mph on Statcast, hasn’t been enough to compensate for his erratic fielding. He’s making the routine plays look difficult, and the difficult plays look impossible.
For a player once touted as the future of the franchise, the Yankees now face a difficult question: Is Volpe still that cornerstone, the player they envisioned anchoring their infield for years to come? Or is he just another young talent who peaked early, a fleeting glimpse of what might have been? If Caballero provides a steady presence at shortstop, Boone and the front office may be forced to make a decision they’ve long tried to avoid: relegating Volpe to a bench role, or perhaps even exploring a trade.
At just 24 years old, Volpe still has time to turn things around. He has the talent, the work ethic, and the potential to reclaim his place as a premier defensive shortstop. But for the Yankees, time is a luxury they can’t afford. They're in win-now mode, and Volpe’s defensive woes are threatening to derail their season. The young shortstop stands at a critical juncture in his career, and his future, both with the Yankees and in the league, hangs precariously in the balance. The ghost of gloves past haunts him, a stark reminder of the high expectations he has yet to fulfill. The question now is, can he exorcise those demons and reclaim his promise, or will he become another cautionary tale of unfulfilled potential? The answer, as they say, remains to be seen.
Two years ago, Volpe burst onto the scene, a whirlwind of leather and grit, flashing a defensive prowess that earned him a Gold Glove in his rookie campaign. He was the defensive anchor of a team desperately searching for stability, a beacon of hope amidst a sputtering offense. His bat lagged, sure, his .283 OBP a glaring weakness in an otherwise promising profile. But the glove, oh that glove. It was enough, we were told. It was the bedrock upon which a future star would be built. He was the heir apparent to the legacy of Jeter, the next great Yankee shortstop.
Fast forward to the present, and the narrative has taken a decidedly darker turn. Volpe’s glove, once his saving grace, has become his albatross. The errors have piled up like dirty laundry, 16 so far this season, trailing only Cincinnati’s Elly De La Cruz in the dubious race for most miscues. He’s held, or shared, the inglorious title of league leader in errors multiple times this summer, each bobble, each misplayed grounder, a dagger in the heart of the Yankees’ playoff aspirations.
And these aren’t just harmless flubs, little hiccups in an otherwise solid performance. These errors have come at crucial junctures, costing the Yankees close games and fueling the growing chorus of discontent from fans and analysts alike. The whispers have turned to shouts, questioning Manager Aaron Boone’s unwavering loyalty to the struggling shortstop. Boone, ever the optimist, continues to publicly praise Volpe’s talent and work ethic, but even his pronouncements are starting to ring hollow in the face of mounting evidence. How long can he justify sticking with a player whose defensive liabilities are actively sabotaging the team’s chances?
The advanced metrics only serve to confirm what our eyes have been telling us all along. Volpe’s Fielding Run Value has plummeted from a respectable +8 in 2024 to a dismal -6 this season. Outs Above Average, another key defensive indicator, tells a similar story: a precipitous drop from +13 to -8. He's struggling on balls hit to his left, to his right, even those seemingly easy plays right in front of him. The once-elite defender is now a defensive black hole, sucking the life out of the infield and contributing to the Yankees’ inconsistent performance.
The trade deadline offered a glimmer of hope, a chance for the Yankees to address their glaring shortstop problem. But instead of acquiring a proven veteran, they swung a curious mid-game deal with Tampa Bay for Jose Caballero. The timing was bizarre, the move itself puzzling. Caballero, while a serviceable player, wasn't exactly a game-changer. He was, at best, a stopgap, a temporary solution to a long-term problem. And even he hasn't been immune to the defensive woes that seem to plague the Yankees infield, committing a costly error in the outfield that contributed to a recent loss against the Marlins.
Ironically, in that very same game, Volpe provided a fleeting reminder of his potential, launching a late-inning home run that briefly gave the Yankees the lead. But the lead, like so many others this season, evaporated, snatched away by the very defensive deficiencies that Volpe embodies. This has been the story of his 2025 season: flashes of brilliance interspersed with frustratingly frequent lapses in judgment and execution.
The decision to bench Volpe today is more than just a routine rest day. It’s a tacit acknowledgment that the Yankees are at a crossroads. With the postseason race tightening, every out is magnified, every error amplified. The margin for error is shrinking, and Volpe’s defensive struggles have become too costly to ignore. His arm, while still registering a respectable 82 mph on Statcast, hasn’t been enough to compensate for his erratic fielding. He’s making the routine plays look difficult, and the difficult plays look impossible.
For a player once touted as the future of the franchise, the Yankees now face a difficult question: Is Volpe still that cornerstone, the player they envisioned anchoring their infield for years to come? Or is he just another young talent who peaked early, a fleeting glimpse of what might have been? If Caballero provides a steady presence at shortstop, Boone and the front office may be forced to make a decision they’ve long tried to avoid: relegating Volpe to a bench role, or perhaps even exploring a trade.
At just 24 years old, Volpe still has time to turn things around. He has the talent, the work ethic, and the potential to reclaim his place as a premier defensive shortstop. But for the Yankees, time is a luxury they can’t afford. They're in win-now mode, and Volpe’s defensive woes are threatening to derail their season. The young shortstop stands at a critical juncture in his career, and his future, both with the Yankees and in the league, hangs precariously in the balance. The ghost of gloves past haunts him, a stark reminder of the high expectations he has yet to fulfill. The question now is, can he exorcise those demons and reclaim his promise, or will he become another cautionary tale of unfulfilled potential? The answer, as they say, remains to be seen.
Back to news