The Bronx Bomber's Bullpen Blues and the Ballad of the Broadcasting Buccaneer
Published on: September 7, 2025
The late innings in the Bronx have become less a fortress of fire and more a flickering candle in the wind. A bullpen envisioned as a lockdown leviathan, a Cerberus guarding the gates of October, is instead resembling a nervous chihuahua, yipping at shadows and occasionally wetting the rug. And adding fuel to this dumpster fire of despair is the curious case of Michael Kay, the Yankees’ play-by-play man, who seems to be struggling with control issues of his own – albeit of a decidedly non-baseball variety.
Let's start with the on-field debacle. The Yankees, with visions of champagne showers and Commissioner's Trophy selfies dancing in their heads, swung a deadline deal for Camilo Doval, the San Francisco Giants' flame-throwing closer. Doval, a 2022 All-Star with a slider sharper than a broken beer bottle and a fastball that could melt glaciers, was supposed to be the final piece of the puzzle, the exclamation point on a dominant relief corps.
Instead, he's been more like a misplaced comma, disrupting the flow and leaving everyone scratching their heads. In pinstripes, Doval has morphed from untouchable closer to erratic escape artist. His ERA, bloated like a week-old hot dog, sits north of 4.97, while his WHIP – a stat that measures baserunners allowed per inning – is an alarming 1.895. He still racks up strikeouts, flashes of the old brilliance flickering through the gloom, but his control has vanished like a runner caught leaning the wrong way at first. Walks pile up like unread emails, wild pitches skip past Gary Sanchez’s ghost like errant frisbees, and the pitch clock – that infernal contraption designed to speed up the game – has become Doval’s personal nemesis.
This bullpen meltdown isn't solely Doval’s doing, of course. Devin Williams, another high-leverage acquisition, arrived in New York with the reputation of a relief ace. He possessed a changeup so devastating it could make hitters question their own existence. Sadly, in the Bronx, his ERA has ballooned to 5.60, and blown saves have become a disturbingly regular occurrence. Together, Doval and Williams, the supposed twin towers of late-inning dominance, resemble two wobbly stilt-walkers, threatening to topple over at any moment.
Enter Michael Kay, the voice of the Yankees, a man never shy about sharing his opinions – warranted or otherwise. On a recent broadcast, Kay, with the air of a disappointed schoolmarm, delivered his verdict on Doval: “Not what the Yankees traded for.” He lamented the walks, the wild pitches, the pitch clock violations. He pointed out the stark contrast between Doval’s All-Star past and his present struggles.
And, frankly, Kay wasn't wrong. Doval has looked more like a reclamation project than a playoff linchpin. But the irony, thicker than Yankee Stadium’s pre-game traffic, is that Kay’s critique arrived hot on the heels of his own public relations meltdown.
Just days before chastising Doval, Kay found himself embroiled in a controversy of his own making. Attempting to defend manager Aaron Boone against fan criticism over Boone’s attendance at a college football game on an off-day, Kay veered wildly off course, into a bizarre tangent involving, of all things, hotel room orgies and trapeze artists. Yes, you read that correctly. In a truly baffling analogy, Kay argued that fans shouldn't care about players’ off-field activities, posing the hypothetical question: What if they were "having an orgy in their hotel room?" He then, for reasons known only to himself, embellished the scenario with a vivid description of trapeze artists swinging through the air amidst the aforementioned orgy.
The internet, naturally, exploded. Kay's comments earned him a spot on Awful Announcing and became the subject of widespread mockery on social media. The voice of the Yankees, usually known for his insightful commentary and Bronx Bombers boosterism, suddenly sounded like a character from a Coen Brothers film.
So, when Kay pivoted to criticizing Doval's performance, it landed with the thud of a dropped foul ball. His words, while accurate in assessing Doval’s struggles, were undercut by his own recent foray into the absurd. It's difficult to lecture a struggling reliever about focus and composure when you’ve just introduced the phrase "trapeze orgy" into the lexicon of sports broadcasting.
The Yankees, desperate for a playoff berth, desperately need Doval to rediscover his San Francisco form. They need Williams to harness his otherworldly changeup. They need the entire bullpen to solidify into the impenetrable force it was meant to be. And maybe, just maybe, Michael Kay needs to stick to analyzing sliders and fastballs, leaving the bizarre analogies and hypothetical orgies in the locker room where they belong.
Because right now, in the Bronx, control issues seem to be contagious, both on the mound and in the broadcast booth. The fate of the Yankees' season, and perhaps Kay’s credibility, hangs in the balance. The late innings, once a source of comfort, have become a high-wire act, and the only trapeze in sight seems to be swinging wildly in Michael Kay’s imagination.
Let's start with the on-field debacle. The Yankees, with visions of champagne showers and Commissioner's Trophy selfies dancing in their heads, swung a deadline deal for Camilo Doval, the San Francisco Giants' flame-throwing closer. Doval, a 2022 All-Star with a slider sharper than a broken beer bottle and a fastball that could melt glaciers, was supposed to be the final piece of the puzzle, the exclamation point on a dominant relief corps.
Instead, he's been more like a misplaced comma, disrupting the flow and leaving everyone scratching their heads. In pinstripes, Doval has morphed from untouchable closer to erratic escape artist. His ERA, bloated like a week-old hot dog, sits north of 4.97, while his WHIP – a stat that measures baserunners allowed per inning – is an alarming 1.895. He still racks up strikeouts, flashes of the old brilliance flickering through the gloom, but his control has vanished like a runner caught leaning the wrong way at first. Walks pile up like unread emails, wild pitches skip past Gary Sanchez’s ghost like errant frisbees, and the pitch clock – that infernal contraption designed to speed up the game – has become Doval’s personal nemesis.
This bullpen meltdown isn't solely Doval’s doing, of course. Devin Williams, another high-leverage acquisition, arrived in New York with the reputation of a relief ace. He possessed a changeup so devastating it could make hitters question their own existence. Sadly, in the Bronx, his ERA has ballooned to 5.60, and blown saves have become a disturbingly regular occurrence. Together, Doval and Williams, the supposed twin towers of late-inning dominance, resemble two wobbly stilt-walkers, threatening to topple over at any moment.
Enter Michael Kay, the voice of the Yankees, a man never shy about sharing his opinions – warranted or otherwise. On a recent broadcast, Kay, with the air of a disappointed schoolmarm, delivered his verdict on Doval: “Not what the Yankees traded for.” He lamented the walks, the wild pitches, the pitch clock violations. He pointed out the stark contrast between Doval’s All-Star past and his present struggles.
And, frankly, Kay wasn't wrong. Doval has looked more like a reclamation project than a playoff linchpin. But the irony, thicker than Yankee Stadium’s pre-game traffic, is that Kay’s critique arrived hot on the heels of his own public relations meltdown.
Just days before chastising Doval, Kay found himself embroiled in a controversy of his own making. Attempting to defend manager Aaron Boone against fan criticism over Boone’s attendance at a college football game on an off-day, Kay veered wildly off course, into a bizarre tangent involving, of all things, hotel room orgies and trapeze artists. Yes, you read that correctly. In a truly baffling analogy, Kay argued that fans shouldn't care about players’ off-field activities, posing the hypothetical question: What if they were "having an orgy in their hotel room?" He then, for reasons known only to himself, embellished the scenario with a vivid description of trapeze artists swinging through the air amidst the aforementioned orgy.
The internet, naturally, exploded. Kay's comments earned him a spot on Awful Announcing and became the subject of widespread mockery on social media. The voice of the Yankees, usually known for his insightful commentary and Bronx Bombers boosterism, suddenly sounded like a character from a Coen Brothers film.
So, when Kay pivoted to criticizing Doval's performance, it landed with the thud of a dropped foul ball. His words, while accurate in assessing Doval’s struggles, were undercut by his own recent foray into the absurd. It's difficult to lecture a struggling reliever about focus and composure when you’ve just introduced the phrase "trapeze orgy" into the lexicon of sports broadcasting.
The Yankees, desperate for a playoff berth, desperately need Doval to rediscover his San Francisco form. They need Williams to harness his otherworldly changeup. They need the entire bullpen to solidify into the impenetrable force it was meant to be. And maybe, just maybe, Michael Kay needs to stick to analyzing sliders and fastballs, leaving the bizarre analogies and hypothetical orgies in the locker room where they belong.
Because right now, in the Bronx, control issues seem to be contagious, both on the mound and in the broadcast booth. The fate of the Yankees' season, and perhaps Kay’s credibility, hangs in the balance. The late innings, once a source of comfort, have become a high-wire act, and the only trapeze in sight seems to be swinging wildly in Michael Kay’s imagination.
Back to news