The Big Dinger's Shadow: Cal Raleigh Muscles His Way into the MVP Conversation
Published on: August 26, 2025
The scent of pine tar and impending fall hangs heavy in the air, but the heat of the American League MVP race is just starting to simmer. While the usual suspects lurk – Judge, Ramirez, a sprinkle of young phenoms – a new slugger has crashed the party, wielding a bat like Thor's hammer and a glare as cold as the Puget Sound. Cal Raleigh, the Seattle Mariners' backstop extraordinaire, isn't just knocking dingers; he's knocking on the door of MVP contention, and the sound is deafening.
A recent MLB.com poll of 37 baseball experts placed Raleigh squarely at the top, a seismic shift in a race previously dominated by the towering presence of Aaron Judge. This isn't some fluke, some flash in the pan powered by a lucky streak. Raleigh's ascent has been a steady climb, built on a foundation of crushed baseballs and a will of iron.
"As Raleigh’s homer total has continued to rise – he's on pace for 60 – his standing in this poll has also surged upward," noted BBWAA member Jason Foster. And surge it has. Raleigh has not only surpassed Judge in this recent poll but has done so with an air of inevitability, like a tide rolling in to reclaim the shore.
The numbers tell a compelling story. Raleigh's 50 home runs – and counting – represent not only a personal milestone but a historic one. He's the first primary catcher to reach the 50-homer plateau, etching his name into baseball lore alongside the legends of the game. Coupled with 107 RBIs and a 168 OPS+, Raleigh isn't just hitting for power; he's driving in runs and doing so with an efficiency that has opposing pitchers shaking their heads in disbelief.
Let's not forget the context. We're talking about a catcher, a position traditionally known more for its defensive prowess than offensive fireworks. Raleigh is rewriting the script, proving that a backstop can be both a wall behind the plate and a wrecking ball at it. He's a throwback to a bygone era of catchers who could rake, but with a modern twist of athleticism and raw power.
While Judge boasts a higher bWAR (6.9 to Raleigh's 5.9) and a truly eye-popping 202 OPS+, Raleigh's recent surge has coincided with a noticeable dip in Judge's production. Since the All-Star break, the Yankee slugger has hit a pedestrian .195/.349/.402, a stark contrast to his pre-break dominance. Baseball, as they say, is a game of momentum, and right now, that momentum belongs to Raleigh.
Their fWAR, however, tells a different story. Both sit at an impressive 7.3, a testament to their overall value to their respective teams. This underscores the complexity of the MVP debate, a nuanced argument that goes beyond simple home run totals and RBI counts. It's about the complete package, the impact a player has on every facet of the game.
While Raleigh's power numbers are undeniably impressive, Judge's superior on-base percentage and overall offensive efficiency, as reflected in his wRC+ of 193 compared to Raleigh's 161, keep him firmly in the conversation. This isn't a David versus Goliath narrative; it's a clash of titans, a battle between two of the most dominant offensive forces in the American League.
The MVP race is far from over. The likes of Bobby Witt Jr., Jose Ramirez, and Tarik Skubal lurk in the shadows, waiting for an opportunity to pounce. But for now, the spotlight shines brightly on Raleigh, the unlikely hero who has captured the imagination of baseball fans everywhere.
He's not just hitting home runs; he's hitting milestones. He's not just winning games; he's winning hearts. And in a season filled with thrilling performances and unexpected twists, Cal Raleigh's emergence as a legitimate MVP candidate is perhaps the most surprising and captivating story of all. He's the Big Dinger in the Emerald City, and the echoes of his mighty swings are reverberating throughout the baseball world. The question now is: can he sustain this torrid pace and cement his place among the game's elite? Only time will tell, but one thing is for certain: Cal Raleigh has made this MVP race a whole lot more interesting. He's injected a dose of excitement, a jolt of raw power into a contest that was threatening to become predictable. And in a game steeped in tradition and history, sometimes a little unpredictability is exactly what's needed to remind us why we love this sport so much. So, buckle up, baseball fans, because the final stretch of this season promises to be a wild ride, and Cal Raleigh is just getting started.
A recent MLB.com poll of 37 baseball experts placed Raleigh squarely at the top, a seismic shift in a race previously dominated by the towering presence of Aaron Judge. This isn't some fluke, some flash in the pan powered by a lucky streak. Raleigh's ascent has been a steady climb, built on a foundation of crushed baseballs and a will of iron.
"As Raleigh’s homer total has continued to rise – he's on pace for 60 – his standing in this poll has also surged upward," noted BBWAA member Jason Foster. And surge it has. Raleigh has not only surpassed Judge in this recent poll but has done so with an air of inevitability, like a tide rolling in to reclaim the shore.
The numbers tell a compelling story. Raleigh's 50 home runs – and counting – represent not only a personal milestone but a historic one. He's the first primary catcher to reach the 50-homer plateau, etching his name into baseball lore alongside the legends of the game. Coupled with 107 RBIs and a 168 OPS+, Raleigh isn't just hitting for power; he's driving in runs and doing so with an efficiency that has opposing pitchers shaking their heads in disbelief.
Let's not forget the context. We're talking about a catcher, a position traditionally known more for its defensive prowess than offensive fireworks. Raleigh is rewriting the script, proving that a backstop can be both a wall behind the plate and a wrecking ball at it. He's a throwback to a bygone era of catchers who could rake, but with a modern twist of athleticism and raw power.
While Judge boasts a higher bWAR (6.9 to Raleigh's 5.9) and a truly eye-popping 202 OPS+, Raleigh's recent surge has coincided with a noticeable dip in Judge's production. Since the All-Star break, the Yankee slugger has hit a pedestrian .195/.349/.402, a stark contrast to his pre-break dominance. Baseball, as they say, is a game of momentum, and right now, that momentum belongs to Raleigh.
Their fWAR, however, tells a different story. Both sit at an impressive 7.3, a testament to their overall value to their respective teams. This underscores the complexity of the MVP debate, a nuanced argument that goes beyond simple home run totals and RBI counts. It's about the complete package, the impact a player has on every facet of the game.
While Raleigh's power numbers are undeniably impressive, Judge's superior on-base percentage and overall offensive efficiency, as reflected in his wRC+ of 193 compared to Raleigh's 161, keep him firmly in the conversation. This isn't a David versus Goliath narrative; it's a clash of titans, a battle between two of the most dominant offensive forces in the American League.
The MVP race is far from over. The likes of Bobby Witt Jr., Jose Ramirez, and Tarik Skubal lurk in the shadows, waiting for an opportunity to pounce. But for now, the spotlight shines brightly on Raleigh, the unlikely hero who has captured the imagination of baseball fans everywhere.
He's not just hitting home runs; he's hitting milestones. He's not just winning games; he's winning hearts. And in a season filled with thrilling performances and unexpected twists, Cal Raleigh's emergence as a legitimate MVP candidate is perhaps the most surprising and captivating story of all. He's the Big Dinger in the Emerald City, and the echoes of his mighty swings are reverberating throughout the baseball world. The question now is: can he sustain this torrid pace and cement his place among the game's elite? Only time will tell, but one thing is for certain: Cal Raleigh has made this MVP race a whole lot more interesting. He's injected a dose of excitement, a jolt of raw power into a contest that was threatening to become predictable. And in a game steeped in tradition and history, sometimes a little unpredictability is exactly what's needed to remind us why we love this sport so much. So, buckle up, baseball fans, because the final stretch of this season promises to be a wild ride, and Cal Raleigh is just getting started.
Back to news