Bronx Bombers' Bullpen: A Sleeping Giant or Just Snoring?
Published on: September 7, 2025
Fernando Cruz, the fiery right-hander who’s become a key cog in the Yankees' often-maligned bullpen, dropped a bombshell after Saturday’s hard-fought 3-1 victory over the Toronto Blue Jays. "I don’t think there’s a bullpen better than us," he declared, his words hanging in the air like the late-summer humidity that’s blanketed the Bronx for weeks. Bold words, considering the roller coaster ride that has been the Yankees' relief corps this season, a ride more akin to a rickety Coney Island contraption than the smooth, efficient machine it was projected to be.
Now, before you grab your torches and pitchforks, Yankee fans, let's examine Cruz’s claim. On paper, he has a point. This bullpen, boasting names like Devin Williams, Luke Weaver, David Bednar, Camilo Doval, and Cruz himself, reads like a fantasy baseball owner’s dream. The raw talent is undeniable. The velocity is there. The nasty breaking stuff? In spades. But as any seasoned baseball observer knows, potential is a fickle mistress, and the Yankees' pen, for much of this season, has been a testament to that very fact.
Their collective ERA sits at a decidedly un-championship-caliber 21st in the league. Williams, the supposed closer-in-waiting, has battled inconsistency, flashing moments of brilliance interspersed with bouts of wildness that would make even the most patient pitching coach tear out his hair. Weaver, once a promising starter, has struggled to find his footing in a relief role, often looking more like a deer caught in headlights than the shutdown arm the Yankees envisioned.
The mid-season acquisitions of Bednar and Doval were supposed to be the stabilizing forces, the veteran presence to calm the choppy waters. And while they've shown flashes of their All-Star potential, their impact hasn’t been the seismic shift many anticipated. The pieces are there, the ingredients for a truly dominant bullpen, but for much of the season, the recipe hasn’t quite come together. It's been a case of too many cooks, each with their own specialty, but lacking a cohesive culinary vision.
Cruz, however, remains undeterred. He sees the potential, the dormant power waiting to be unleashed. "As soon as we flip the switch that we need to go, it’s gonna be scary," he promised, his eyes flashing with the same intensity he brings to the mound. And it's that intensity, that raw, unbridled passion, that has made him a fan favorite in the Bronx. He’s the embodiment of the city’s grit and fire, a modern-day Sparky Lyle, unafraid to challenge hitters and wear his emotions on his sleeve.
Manager Aaron Boone, a man who knows a thing or two about playing under the bright lights of New York, appreciates Cruz’s fervor. “I love it as long as you channel it,” Boone remarked, acknowledging the fine line between controlled aggression and destructive recklessness. “A reliever, you can do that a little bit. You can let it out. You can have your hair on fire a little bit.” Boone sees in Cruz the makings of a true late-inning weapon, a guy who thrives under pressure, who wants the ball in the biggest moments. “He loves being a Yankee. He loves his teammates. He loves pitching here in this environment. He wants the ball,” Boone effused, a clear indication of the trust he has in the fiery reliever.
So, back to Cruz’s bold claim: Best bullpen in baseball? Right now, the stats say otherwise. The eye test, for much of the season, has whispered a similar tale. But the Yankees, at 79-63, clinging to the top Wild Card spot and just three games back of the Blue Jays in the AL East, are still very much in the hunt. And if this team, with its potent lineup and occasionally brilliant starting pitching, is going to make a serious postseason run, they’ll need their bullpen to finally live up to its billing.
They need Williams to harness his electric stuff and become the lockdown closer they envisioned. They need Weaver to find his rhythm and embrace his role as a bridge to the late innings. They need Bednar and Doval to provide the veteran leadership and consistency that has been lacking. And they need Cruz to continue to be the fiery, emotional spark plug that ignites the entire unit.
Perhaps Cruz’s proclamation wasn’t just bravado, but a prophecy. Perhaps it was a challenge to himself and his teammates, a call to arms for a bullpen teetering on the brink of greatness. The talent is there. The potential is undeniable. Now, with the season winding down and the stakes higher than ever, it's time for the Yankees' bullpen to either wake up and become the monster they were meant to be, or continue to slumber, a collection of impressive names that never quite lived up to the hype. The clock is ticking. The Bronx is waiting. Let the games begin.
Now, before you grab your torches and pitchforks, Yankee fans, let's examine Cruz’s claim. On paper, he has a point. This bullpen, boasting names like Devin Williams, Luke Weaver, David Bednar, Camilo Doval, and Cruz himself, reads like a fantasy baseball owner’s dream. The raw talent is undeniable. The velocity is there. The nasty breaking stuff? In spades. But as any seasoned baseball observer knows, potential is a fickle mistress, and the Yankees' pen, for much of this season, has been a testament to that very fact.
Their collective ERA sits at a decidedly un-championship-caliber 21st in the league. Williams, the supposed closer-in-waiting, has battled inconsistency, flashing moments of brilliance interspersed with bouts of wildness that would make even the most patient pitching coach tear out his hair. Weaver, once a promising starter, has struggled to find his footing in a relief role, often looking more like a deer caught in headlights than the shutdown arm the Yankees envisioned.
The mid-season acquisitions of Bednar and Doval were supposed to be the stabilizing forces, the veteran presence to calm the choppy waters. And while they've shown flashes of their All-Star potential, their impact hasn’t been the seismic shift many anticipated. The pieces are there, the ingredients for a truly dominant bullpen, but for much of the season, the recipe hasn’t quite come together. It's been a case of too many cooks, each with their own specialty, but lacking a cohesive culinary vision.
Cruz, however, remains undeterred. He sees the potential, the dormant power waiting to be unleashed. "As soon as we flip the switch that we need to go, it’s gonna be scary," he promised, his eyes flashing with the same intensity he brings to the mound. And it's that intensity, that raw, unbridled passion, that has made him a fan favorite in the Bronx. He’s the embodiment of the city’s grit and fire, a modern-day Sparky Lyle, unafraid to challenge hitters and wear his emotions on his sleeve.
Manager Aaron Boone, a man who knows a thing or two about playing under the bright lights of New York, appreciates Cruz’s fervor. “I love it as long as you channel it,” Boone remarked, acknowledging the fine line between controlled aggression and destructive recklessness. “A reliever, you can do that a little bit. You can let it out. You can have your hair on fire a little bit.” Boone sees in Cruz the makings of a true late-inning weapon, a guy who thrives under pressure, who wants the ball in the biggest moments. “He loves being a Yankee. He loves his teammates. He loves pitching here in this environment. He wants the ball,” Boone effused, a clear indication of the trust he has in the fiery reliever.
So, back to Cruz’s bold claim: Best bullpen in baseball? Right now, the stats say otherwise. The eye test, for much of the season, has whispered a similar tale. But the Yankees, at 79-63, clinging to the top Wild Card spot and just three games back of the Blue Jays in the AL East, are still very much in the hunt. And if this team, with its potent lineup and occasionally brilliant starting pitching, is going to make a serious postseason run, they’ll need their bullpen to finally live up to its billing.
They need Williams to harness his electric stuff and become the lockdown closer they envisioned. They need Weaver to find his rhythm and embrace his role as a bridge to the late innings. They need Bednar and Doval to provide the veteran leadership and consistency that has been lacking. And they need Cruz to continue to be the fiery, emotional spark plug that ignites the entire unit.
Perhaps Cruz’s proclamation wasn’t just bravado, but a prophecy. Perhaps it was a challenge to himself and his teammates, a call to arms for a bullpen teetering on the brink of greatness. The talent is there. The potential is undeniable. Now, with the season winding down and the stakes higher than ever, it's time for the Yankees' bullpen to either wake up and become the monster they were meant to be, or continue to slumber, a collection of impressive names that never quite lived up to the hype. The clock is ticking. The Bronx is waiting. Let the games begin.
Back to news