The Amish Hammer: Is Nick Kurtz Forging a Judge-ian Legacy?
Published on: August 28, 2025
The crack of the bat echoes through the Oakland Coliseum, a sound increasingly familiar yet still somehow shocking. It’s not just the decibels; it’s the way the ball explodes off the bat, a violent symphony of physics that sends the sphere hurtling towards the bleachers with the trajectory of a rocket launch. It’s a sound that’s been echoing in the Bronx for years, a sound synonymous with one name: Aaron Judge. Now, it’s being replicated in Oakland by a rookie who, remarkably, seems to be swinging from the same blueprint: Nick Kurtz, “The Big Amish.”
Comparisons to established stars are the lifeblood of prospect hype, often flimsy bridges built on hope and a handful of promising at-bats. But with Kurtz, the parallels to Judge aren't just anecdotal; they’re rooted in the hard data, the kind of quantifiable metrics that are revolutionizing the way we understand hitting. It’s not just about the imposing stature – though Kurtz, at 6-foot-5 and 240 pounds, practically mirrors Judge’s physical presence. It's about the mechanics, the raw power, the almost uncanny similarity in their swings.
Eno Sarris of The Athletic, a veritable Sherlock Holmes of swing analysis, has dissected the numbers, zeroing in on bat speed and swing tilt, the two key variables that define a hitter’s power profile. Kurtz, it turns out, averages a blistering 77.5 mph bat speed, placing him firmly amongst the league’s elite. His average swing tilt through the zone clocks in at 39 degrees, a launch angle practically engineered for sending baseballs into orbit. These aren’t just good numbers for a rookie; they’re eerily close to Judge’s own metrics. Judge, according to Baseball Savant, operates with an average bat speed hovering around 76.9 mph and a 38-degree tilt. Shohei Ohtani, another name whispered in the same breath as Kurtz, sits at 76.1 mph and 37 degrees. Line up these swings side-by-side, and you’re looking at a rookie who’s moving like two of the most feared sluggers in the modern game.
But the similarities don’t end there. Kurtz, like Judge, exhibits a preternatural ability to let the ball travel deep into the zone, his point of contact mirroring Judge's more closely than any other player in the league. This, combined with his elite bat speed, translates into the kind of opposite-field power typically reserved for the game’s upper echelon. We're not talking about cheap, wind-aided bloops down the line; we’re talking about majestic blasts that clear the fences with authority, the kind that leave outfielders shaking their heads in admiration, or perhaps, a touch of fear.
For Yankees fans, the comparisons are both thrilling and unsettling. Judge’s journey, from towering prospect to Yankee Stadium icon, is a recent memory, a testament to the power of raw talent honed by discipline and hard work. Kurtz appears to be tracing that same trajectory, already leading all rookies in on-base percentage, slugging percentage, home runs, and Wins Above Replacement – the holy quartet of offensive statistics.
The Athletic’s analysis places Kurtz in an exclusive club with Judge and Ohtani, based purely on swing characteristics. Relax the bat speed criteria slightly, and the group expands to include a certain Mike Trout. That’s the company Kurtz is keeping just a few months into his big league career. Heady stuff for a kid from Lancaster, Pennsylvania, a place better known for horse-drawn buggies than towering home runs.
And then there's the nickname. "The Big Amish," a moniker that speaks to his Pennsylvania Dutch roots, adds another layer to the burgeoning Kurtz legend. It evokes a certain aura, a larger-than-life presence at the plate, reminiscent of the early days of Judge, when he was transforming from promising prospect into the face of a franchise. The lesson from Judge’s career applies here: raw metrics alone don't guarantee superstardom. But when coupled with plate discipline, consistent approach, and the ability to make adjustments, they can be the foundation for a perennial MVP candidate.
The challenge for Kurtz, as with any young power hitter, lies in translating his prodigious swing into consistent, year-over-year production. The Athletic rightly cautions that there will be swing-and-miss tendencies, particularly against high fastballs, a vulnerability that Judge himself has battled throughout his career. But the raw ingredients are there, the potential undeniable. The numbers suggest that Kurtz’s ceiling is as high as anyone’s in the game.
For the Yankees, witnessing another hitter mirroring Judge’s early metrics is a double-edged sword. It validates the sheer uniqueness of Judge’s swing, the rare confluence of size, speed, and mechanics that makes him such a force of nature. But it also serves as a stark reminder that a rival franchise may have unearthed its own version of the Yankee captain, a player capable of replicating, and perhaps even surpassing, Judge’s impact.
The baseball world is watching, captivated by the emergence of this Amish Hammer. If Nick Kurtz can sustain this trajectory, the comparisons to Aaron Judge won’t just be statistical; they’ll be historical. The echoes in Oakland might just become louder than the roars in the Bronx. And that, my friends, is a truly fascinating prospect.
Comparisons to established stars are the lifeblood of prospect hype, often flimsy bridges built on hope and a handful of promising at-bats. But with Kurtz, the parallels to Judge aren't just anecdotal; they’re rooted in the hard data, the kind of quantifiable metrics that are revolutionizing the way we understand hitting. It’s not just about the imposing stature – though Kurtz, at 6-foot-5 and 240 pounds, practically mirrors Judge’s physical presence. It's about the mechanics, the raw power, the almost uncanny similarity in their swings.
Eno Sarris of The Athletic, a veritable Sherlock Holmes of swing analysis, has dissected the numbers, zeroing in on bat speed and swing tilt, the two key variables that define a hitter’s power profile. Kurtz, it turns out, averages a blistering 77.5 mph bat speed, placing him firmly amongst the league’s elite. His average swing tilt through the zone clocks in at 39 degrees, a launch angle practically engineered for sending baseballs into orbit. These aren’t just good numbers for a rookie; they’re eerily close to Judge’s own metrics. Judge, according to Baseball Savant, operates with an average bat speed hovering around 76.9 mph and a 38-degree tilt. Shohei Ohtani, another name whispered in the same breath as Kurtz, sits at 76.1 mph and 37 degrees. Line up these swings side-by-side, and you’re looking at a rookie who’s moving like two of the most feared sluggers in the modern game.
But the similarities don’t end there. Kurtz, like Judge, exhibits a preternatural ability to let the ball travel deep into the zone, his point of contact mirroring Judge's more closely than any other player in the league. This, combined with his elite bat speed, translates into the kind of opposite-field power typically reserved for the game’s upper echelon. We're not talking about cheap, wind-aided bloops down the line; we’re talking about majestic blasts that clear the fences with authority, the kind that leave outfielders shaking their heads in admiration, or perhaps, a touch of fear.
For Yankees fans, the comparisons are both thrilling and unsettling. Judge’s journey, from towering prospect to Yankee Stadium icon, is a recent memory, a testament to the power of raw talent honed by discipline and hard work. Kurtz appears to be tracing that same trajectory, already leading all rookies in on-base percentage, slugging percentage, home runs, and Wins Above Replacement – the holy quartet of offensive statistics.
The Athletic’s analysis places Kurtz in an exclusive club with Judge and Ohtani, based purely on swing characteristics. Relax the bat speed criteria slightly, and the group expands to include a certain Mike Trout. That’s the company Kurtz is keeping just a few months into his big league career. Heady stuff for a kid from Lancaster, Pennsylvania, a place better known for horse-drawn buggies than towering home runs.
And then there's the nickname. "The Big Amish," a moniker that speaks to his Pennsylvania Dutch roots, adds another layer to the burgeoning Kurtz legend. It evokes a certain aura, a larger-than-life presence at the plate, reminiscent of the early days of Judge, when he was transforming from promising prospect into the face of a franchise. The lesson from Judge’s career applies here: raw metrics alone don't guarantee superstardom. But when coupled with plate discipline, consistent approach, and the ability to make adjustments, they can be the foundation for a perennial MVP candidate.
The challenge for Kurtz, as with any young power hitter, lies in translating his prodigious swing into consistent, year-over-year production. The Athletic rightly cautions that there will be swing-and-miss tendencies, particularly against high fastballs, a vulnerability that Judge himself has battled throughout his career. But the raw ingredients are there, the potential undeniable. The numbers suggest that Kurtz’s ceiling is as high as anyone’s in the game.
For the Yankees, witnessing another hitter mirroring Judge’s early metrics is a double-edged sword. It validates the sheer uniqueness of Judge’s swing, the rare confluence of size, speed, and mechanics that makes him such a force of nature. But it also serves as a stark reminder that a rival franchise may have unearthed its own version of the Yankee captain, a player capable of replicating, and perhaps even surpassing, Judge’s impact.
The baseball world is watching, captivated by the emergence of this Amish Hammer. If Nick Kurtz can sustain this trajectory, the comparisons to Aaron Judge won’t just be statistical; they’ll be historical. The echoes in Oakland might just become louder than the roars in the Bronx. And that, my friends, is a truly fascinating prospect.
Back to news