Stro Show Turns Into No-Show: Yankees' Rotation Springs Another Leak
Published on: July 27, 2025
The Bronx Bombers were looking for a steady hand on the tiller Saturday afternoon. Instead, they got Marcus Stroman, and he proceeded to steer the good ship Yankee right into a Philadelphia-sized iceberg. The veteran righty, brought in to provide stability, delivered only instability, serving up batting practice fastballs to a Phillies lineup that treated him like a piñata in a 9-4 drubbing. With the Captain, Aaron Judge, sidelined with elbow woes, the Yankees desperately needed Stroman to eat innings and keep them in the game. What they got instead was a five-inning, nine-hit, four-earned-run mess that left the bullpen overworked and the Yankees further adrift in the increasingly choppy waters of the AL playoff race.
This wasn’t just a bad outing; it was a public dismantling. The kind of performance that makes you question everything you thought you knew about a pitcher. Stroman, normally a crafty veteran who relies on deception and movement, looked utterly lost, his arsenal as effective as a soggy firecracker on the Fourth of July. The Statcast data paints a gruesome picture: a max exit velocity of 109.1 mph off the bat of a Phillies hitter—that's not a baseball leaving the yard, that’s a missile launch. The average exit velocity, a still-scorching 96.0 mph across 89 pitches, tells the story of a pitcher who couldn’t generate weak contact if his life depended on it. Nearly everything he threw in the zone came back at him with the ferocity of a line drive off the Green Monster.
It wasn’t a matter of predictable pitch sequencing. Stroman, to his credit, mixed his six-pitch repertoire – sinker, cutter, splitter, slider, curveball, and four-seamer – with his usual precision. The problem wasn’t what he threw, it was how he threw it. Everything lacked its usual bite. His sinker, usually a ground-ball-inducing weapon, averaged a blistering 99.6 mph exit velocity off the bat. The cutter, arguably his most reliable offering this season and thrown 25 times, fared even worse, getting tattooed to the tune of a 101.5 mph average exit velocity. Forget death by a thousand cuts; this was death by a thousand rockets.
The whiff rates were equally abysmal. His sinker, cutter, and splitter all generated below-average swing-and-misses, and not a single pitch induced more than two called strikes. Across 39 swings, Stroman managed a paltry nine whiffs, a whiff rate of just 23%. The Phillies weren’t guessing; they were sitting on pitches, recognizing them out of hand and teeing off. They weren’t just early; they were on time, and often, ahead of everything Stroman threw.
Velocity wasn't the issue. Stroman's sinker hummed along at its usual 90.0 mph, and the cutter zipped in at 88.8 mph. The problem was the lack of deception. The induced vertical break and horizontal movement were down or flat across most offerings, making everything look like it was on a tee. Even his slider, usually a put-away pitch against right-handed hitters, didn’t record a single whiff. The Phillies’ hitters were treating his breaking pitches like BP.
The real damage, however, came with runners on base. Stroman simply couldn't locate his slurve or splitter consistently enough to escape jams. His 10 splitters generated a mere three whiffs and multiple balls in play at 94+ mph, including one screaming liner that nearly degloved him. His overall CSW% (Called Strikes + Whiffs), a crucial metric for evaluating a pitcher's effectiveness, was a dismal 21%, well below league average for starting pitchers. This wasn't just a case of the Phillies being hot; this was Stroman being ice cold.
The implications of this meltdown extend far beyond a single loss. The Yankees brought Stroman in to be an innings-eater, a stabilizing force in a rotation riddled with injuries and inconsistencies. Instead, his ERA has ballooned in July, and this outing felt like rock bottom. This marked the third time in his last four starts that he failed to reach the sixth inning, further taxing a bullpen already stretched thin.
With Clarke Schmidt lost for the season to Tommy John surgery and Aaron Judge nursing a flexor strain in his throwing arm, the Yankees' margin for error is razor-thin. Stroman's struggles amplify the urgency for action at the trade deadline. If he can't find a way to reverse course, and quickly, General Manager Brian Cashman may be forced to explore the market for another starter. The Yankees, already playing catch-up in the AL East, simply can't afford to have a black hole in their rotation every fifth day.
While the credit for Saturday's offensive explosion rightly belongs to the Phillies, a team built to punish mistakes, they didn’t exactly have to work for it. Stroman's cutter consistently caught too much of the plate, his sinker lacked its usual bite, and his off-speed pitches were elevated and hittable. The result was a lopsided loss that extended the Yankees' recent slide and raised serious questions about the viability of their starting rotation.
For now, Stroman’s spot in the rotation appears safe, if only due to a lack of viable alternatives. But with each shaky outing, the pressure mounts. The Yankees are fighting to stay relevant in a cutthroat AL playoff race, and they desperately need Stroman to rediscover the form that made him a valuable veteran presence. If he can't, the Yankees’ October dreams might be extinguished before the leaves even begin to change color in the Bronx.
This wasn’t just a bad outing; it was a public dismantling. The kind of performance that makes you question everything you thought you knew about a pitcher. Stroman, normally a crafty veteran who relies on deception and movement, looked utterly lost, his arsenal as effective as a soggy firecracker on the Fourth of July. The Statcast data paints a gruesome picture: a max exit velocity of 109.1 mph off the bat of a Phillies hitter—that's not a baseball leaving the yard, that’s a missile launch. The average exit velocity, a still-scorching 96.0 mph across 89 pitches, tells the story of a pitcher who couldn’t generate weak contact if his life depended on it. Nearly everything he threw in the zone came back at him with the ferocity of a line drive off the Green Monster.
It wasn’t a matter of predictable pitch sequencing. Stroman, to his credit, mixed his six-pitch repertoire – sinker, cutter, splitter, slider, curveball, and four-seamer – with his usual precision. The problem wasn’t what he threw, it was how he threw it. Everything lacked its usual bite. His sinker, usually a ground-ball-inducing weapon, averaged a blistering 99.6 mph exit velocity off the bat. The cutter, arguably his most reliable offering this season and thrown 25 times, fared even worse, getting tattooed to the tune of a 101.5 mph average exit velocity. Forget death by a thousand cuts; this was death by a thousand rockets.
The whiff rates were equally abysmal. His sinker, cutter, and splitter all generated below-average swing-and-misses, and not a single pitch induced more than two called strikes. Across 39 swings, Stroman managed a paltry nine whiffs, a whiff rate of just 23%. The Phillies weren’t guessing; they were sitting on pitches, recognizing them out of hand and teeing off. They weren’t just early; they were on time, and often, ahead of everything Stroman threw.
Velocity wasn't the issue. Stroman's sinker hummed along at its usual 90.0 mph, and the cutter zipped in at 88.8 mph. The problem was the lack of deception. The induced vertical break and horizontal movement were down or flat across most offerings, making everything look like it was on a tee. Even his slider, usually a put-away pitch against right-handed hitters, didn’t record a single whiff. The Phillies’ hitters were treating his breaking pitches like BP.
The real damage, however, came with runners on base. Stroman simply couldn't locate his slurve or splitter consistently enough to escape jams. His 10 splitters generated a mere three whiffs and multiple balls in play at 94+ mph, including one screaming liner that nearly degloved him. His overall CSW% (Called Strikes + Whiffs), a crucial metric for evaluating a pitcher's effectiveness, was a dismal 21%, well below league average for starting pitchers. This wasn't just a case of the Phillies being hot; this was Stroman being ice cold.
The implications of this meltdown extend far beyond a single loss. The Yankees brought Stroman in to be an innings-eater, a stabilizing force in a rotation riddled with injuries and inconsistencies. Instead, his ERA has ballooned in July, and this outing felt like rock bottom. This marked the third time in his last four starts that he failed to reach the sixth inning, further taxing a bullpen already stretched thin.
With Clarke Schmidt lost for the season to Tommy John surgery and Aaron Judge nursing a flexor strain in his throwing arm, the Yankees' margin for error is razor-thin. Stroman's struggles amplify the urgency for action at the trade deadline. If he can't find a way to reverse course, and quickly, General Manager Brian Cashman may be forced to explore the market for another starter. The Yankees, already playing catch-up in the AL East, simply can't afford to have a black hole in their rotation every fifth day.
While the credit for Saturday's offensive explosion rightly belongs to the Phillies, a team built to punish mistakes, they didn’t exactly have to work for it. Stroman's cutter consistently caught too much of the plate, his sinker lacked its usual bite, and his off-speed pitches were elevated and hittable. The result was a lopsided loss that extended the Yankees' recent slide and raised serious questions about the viability of their starting rotation.
For now, Stroman’s spot in the rotation appears safe, if only due to a lack of viable alternatives. But with each shaky outing, the pressure mounts. The Yankees are fighting to stay relevant in a cutthroat AL playoff race, and they desperately need Stroman to rediscover the form that made him a valuable veteran presence. If he can't, the Yankees’ October dreams might be extinguished before the leaves even begin to change color in the Bronx.
Back to news