The Curious Case of Austin Wells: From Starting Backstop to Bronx Benchwarmer
Published on: August 21, 2025
Austin Wells, the young New York Yankees catcher, finds himself in a peculiar predicament. Just months ago, he was the undisputed starter, the man entrusted with guiding the pitching staff and providing a spark in the lineup. Now, he's more spectator than participant, relegated to a supporting role while Ben Rice squats behind the dish. This sudden shift has left many scratching their heads, including Wells himself, who boldly proclaimed himself one of the league’s best catchers despite his dwindling playing time. So, what's the story behind this curious case of the benched backstop?
Let's rewind to the start of the season. Wells was the clear number one, starting 78 of the first 108 games. While his batting average hovered around the Mendoza line (.227), there was a sense of optimism. He was a rookie, finding his feet in the big leagues, and the flashes of power he displayed hinted at a promising future. But baseball, as they say, is a game of adjustments. Pitchers started to figure out Wells, exploiting his weakness against breaking balls. Since mid-July, his average has plummeted to a dismal .206, fueled by a brutal 21-game stretch where he hit a microscopic .123 with a lone homer. His OPS during that slump? A ghastly .356, a number that would make even a Little League coach cringe. These aren't just cold streaks; they’re arctic blasts capable of freezing any hitter’s momentum.
Wells, to his credit, acknowledges the struggles. “These last few weeks I know have not been good for me,” he admitted candidly. He understands that baseball is a results-oriented business. “It’s a results-driven sport. If you’re not getting numbers, you’re probably not going to play.” It's a stark reality, especially in the pressure cooker of the Bronx, where expectations are sky-high. He also understands the difficult position this puts the coaching staff in. "It’s also probably tough for the coaching staff to not see results and want to put me back in the lineup. So it’s tough all around." It's a refreshingly honest assessment from a young player who could easily have resorted to excuses.
But here’s where the story takes a turn. While admitting his recent offensive woes, Wells doubles down on his overall value, claiming he’s one of the league’s best catchers. “If we’re looking at the catching, I’m one of the best catchers in the league,” he declared. It's a bold statement, one that raises eyebrows considering his current predicament. He points to improved production with runners in scoring position and significant growth defensively, particularly in his framing skills. He believes these improvements, though perhaps less visible than batting average, make him an elite catcher.
So, is Wells delusional, or is there merit to his claims? While the advanced metrics may support his defensive improvements, they don't entirely justify his self-proclaimed elite status. Catching is a multifaceted position, requiring a blend of defensive prowess, game-calling acumen, and offensive contribution. While Wells may excel in certain areas, his offensive struggles have overshadowed everything else.
Adding another layer of complexity to this situation is the emergence of Ben Rice. Rice hasn't just filled in; he's thrived. Hitting .239 with 18 home runs and 45 RBIs, Rice has cemented himself as a legitimate everyday option. He’s shown a steady hand behind the plate, earning the trust of the pitching staff and providing consistent offensive production. In baseball parlance, he's playing "winning baseball," and that's hard to ignore.
Then there’s the Paul Goldschmidt factor. The veteran slugger, firmly entrenched at first base, continues to mash left-handed pitching. This creates a logjam in the lineup, limiting opportunities to shift Rice to first base and open up at-bats for Wells. Goldschmidt's production makes him virtually irreplaceable, leaving Wells squeezed out of the equation.
For Wells, the path back to regular playing time is uncertain. He acknowledges Rice’s excellent performance, pledging his support while simultaneously working to regain his own form. “If this is what they think is going to help the team in this moment, then that’s what’s going to help the team,” Wells stated. "And Ben’s doing a great job. He’s raking. If that’s what we’re gonna do, I’m going to support Ben in any way that I can. And at the same time, I’m trying to get better every single day so I can do the same thing as Ben when it’s my turn again.” It’s a mature approach, one that speaks to his character and commitment to the team.
Yankees hitting coach James Rowson has also praised Wells’ dedication and work ethic, acknowledging the frustration that comes with these types of slumps. "Austin is tough as nails,” Rowson commented. “There’s no doubt about it, it’s tough when you go through these spurts as a young player, but his work has been great.” The Yankees clearly still believe in Wells’ potential, valuing his left-handed power and improved defense.
The question now is, what does the future hold for Austin Wells? Can he rediscover his offensive stroke and reclaim his starting role? Or will he remain a bench player, a victim of circumstance and a testament to the fickle nature of baseball? Only time will tell. For now, he's left to grind, to hone his skills, and to wait for another opportunity to prove that his bold claim – that he's one of the league's best catchers – is more than just wishful thinking. This is a story with chapters yet to be written, a baseball drama unfolding in the Bronx, with a young catcher determined to rewrite the narrative.
Let's rewind to the start of the season. Wells was the clear number one, starting 78 of the first 108 games. While his batting average hovered around the Mendoza line (.227), there was a sense of optimism. He was a rookie, finding his feet in the big leagues, and the flashes of power he displayed hinted at a promising future. But baseball, as they say, is a game of adjustments. Pitchers started to figure out Wells, exploiting his weakness against breaking balls. Since mid-July, his average has plummeted to a dismal .206, fueled by a brutal 21-game stretch where he hit a microscopic .123 with a lone homer. His OPS during that slump? A ghastly .356, a number that would make even a Little League coach cringe. These aren't just cold streaks; they’re arctic blasts capable of freezing any hitter’s momentum.
Wells, to his credit, acknowledges the struggles. “These last few weeks I know have not been good for me,” he admitted candidly. He understands that baseball is a results-oriented business. “It’s a results-driven sport. If you’re not getting numbers, you’re probably not going to play.” It's a stark reality, especially in the pressure cooker of the Bronx, where expectations are sky-high. He also understands the difficult position this puts the coaching staff in. "It’s also probably tough for the coaching staff to not see results and want to put me back in the lineup. So it’s tough all around." It's a refreshingly honest assessment from a young player who could easily have resorted to excuses.
But here’s where the story takes a turn. While admitting his recent offensive woes, Wells doubles down on his overall value, claiming he’s one of the league’s best catchers. “If we’re looking at the catching, I’m one of the best catchers in the league,” he declared. It's a bold statement, one that raises eyebrows considering his current predicament. He points to improved production with runners in scoring position and significant growth defensively, particularly in his framing skills. He believes these improvements, though perhaps less visible than batting average, make him an elite catcher.
So, is Wells delusional, or is there merit to his claims? While the advanced metrics may support his defensive improvements, they don't entirely justify his self-proclaimed elite status. Catching is a multifaceted position, requiring a blend of defensive prowess, game-calling acumen, and offensive contribution. While Wells may excel in certain areas, his offensive struggles have overshadowed everything else.
Adding another layer of complexity to this situation is the emergence of Ben Rice. Rice hasn't just filled in; he's thrived. Hitting .239 with 18 home runs and 45 RBIs, Rice has cemented himself as a legitimate everyday option. He’s shown a steady hand behind the plate, earning the trust of the pitching staff and providing consistent offensive production. In baseball parlance, he's playing "winning baseball," and that's hard to ignore.
Then there’s the Paul Goldschmidt factor. The veteran slugger, firmly entrenched at first base, continues to mash left-handed pitching. This creates a logjam in the lineup, limiting opportunities to shift Rice to first base and open up at-bats for Wells. Goldschmidt's production makes him virtually irreplaceable, leaving Wells squeezed out of the equation.
For Wells, the path back to regular playing time is uncertain. He acknowledges Rice’s excellent performance, pledging his support while simultaneously working to regain his own form. “If this is what they think is going to help the team in this moment, then that’s what’s going to help the team,” Wells stated. "And Ben’s doing a great job. He’s raking. If that’s what we’re gonna do, I’m going to support Ben in any way that I can. And at the same time, I’m trying to get better every single day so I can do the same thing as Ben when it’s my turn again.” It’s a mature approach, one that speaks to his character and commitment to the team.
Yankees hitting coach James Rowson has also praised Wells’ dedication and work ethic, acknowledging the frustration that comes with these types of slumps. "Austin is tough as nails,” Rowson commented. “There’s no doubt about it, it’s tough when you go through these spurts as a young player, but his work has been great.” The Yankees clearly still believe in Wells’ potential, valuing his left-handed power and improved defense.
The question now is, what does the future hold for Austin Wells? Can he rediscover his offensive stroke and reclaim his starting role? Or will he remain a bench player, a victim of circumstance and a testament to the fickle nature of baseball? Only time will tell. For now, he's left to grind, to hone his skills, and to wait for another opportunity to prove that his bold claim – that he's one of the league's best catchers – is more than just wishful thinking. This is a story with chapters yet to be written, a baseball drama unfolding in the Bronx, with a young catcher determined to rewrite the narrative.
Back to news