Keller Conundrum: Will the Pirates Part with Their Ace-in-the-Hole, and Can the Yankees Afford Him?
Published on: July 29, 2025
The hot air rising from the trade deadline rumor mill is thick enough to choke a horse, and swirling within it is the name of Pittsburgh Pirates pitcher Mitch Keller. He's the Schrödinger's cat of trade bait: simultaneously coveted and untouchable, depending on which insider’s whispers you choose to lend your ear. Is he a valuable trade chip, ready to be cashed in for a future bounty? Or is he a cornerstone of the Pirates’ slow-burn rebuild, a veteran presence too precious to part with? The baseball world is holding its breath, waiting for the cat to jump.
On one side of the diamond, we have the chorus of "he’s gotta go" pundits. Bob Nightengale, the USA Today scribe with the ear of the front office gods, recently declared that anyone not named Paul Skenes or Oneil Cruz is on the table in Pittsburgh, and that Keller is "still expected to move." This sentiment echoes throughout the baseball blogosphere, with many analysts viewing Keller as a prime target for contending teams desperate for a rotation boost. After all, a pitcher with Keller’s stuff, coupled with three more years of team control at a reasonable price, is the kind of asset that can make a GM’s phone ring off the hook.
But then, just as the trade winds seem to be blowing Keller out of the Steel City, we have the counter-narrative emerging from the Pirates’ camp. Noah Hiles of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, citing multiple sources, reported that Keller is “likely to stay put.” He points to Pirates GM Ben Cherington's recent emphasis on leadership and performance, suggesting that Keller embodies those qualities and is thus deemed essential to the team's long-term vision. Cherington himself, as quoted by Hiles, stated, “If we’re going to be better in 2026, we need more of that, not less. We would only contemplate giving up something that’s seemingly more proven if we really believe that they give us a better chance to be better by next year.” It’s a classic case of the front office playing coy, keeping their cards close to their vest while subtly inflating their player’s value.
This conflicting information leaves us in a state of delightful uncertainty. Is Cherington genuinely committed to building around Keller? Or is he simply posturing, hoping to drive up the price for his prized pitcher? One thing's for sure: Keller’s name is hotter than a jalapeño right now, and any team looking to bolster their rotation would be foolish not to at least kick the tires.
Enter the New York Yankees, stage left, with their pinstripes slightly rumpled and their playoff hopes teetering on the brink. Their season started with promise, a glimpse of the Bronx Bombers of old. But injuries, particularly to their starting rotation, have taken their toll. The Yankees, currently clinging to a wild card spot like a drowning man to a life raft, are desperate for pitching reinforcements. The loss of Gerrit Cole to Tommy John surgery before the season threw a wrench in their plans, and Clarke Schmidt's similar fate has only compounded the problem. GM Brian Cashman, a man used to pulling off blockbuster trades, now finds himself in a precarious position, needing to shore up his rotation without sacrificing the future.
Keller, with his consistent performance and years of control, seems tailor-made for the Yankees’ needs. ESPN’s Jorge Castillo recently argued that Keller, while not the flashiest name on the trade market, would be a "solid addition to a depleted rotation.” He highlighted Keller’s impressive 3.69 ERA over 127 innings, along with his affordable contract, as key factors that make him an attractive target for the Yankees, who generally prefer acquiring players with multiple years of control. Castillo’s assessment is spot-on: Keller offers the Yankees a proven commodity, a steady hand in a rotation that has been plagued by inconsistency and injury.
But acquiring a pitcher of Keller’s caliber won’t come cheap. The Pirates, even if they are willing to part with him, will demand a significant return. Tim Britton of The Athletic suggests that a package of two young “impact players” might be enough to pry Keller loose, with the Pirates likely prioritizing offensive prospects over pitchers. This brings us to the heart of the Yankees’ dilemma: what are they willing to sacrifice to acquire Keller?
Rumors are swirling that the Yankees are open to including outfielder Spencer Jones, their No. 5 prospect, in a trade package. Jones has been tearing up Triple-A pitching since his recent promotion, showcasing the kind of raw talent that makes scouts drool. However, the Yankees would likely require a king's ransom in return to part with a player of his caliber. Another name that has surfaced is Ben Rice, a promising prospect whose path to the majors might be blocked by Aaron Judge's eventual return to the outfield. With Judge seemingly destined for a permanent DH role, Rice’s value to the Yankees has diminished, making him a more expendable trade chip.
A package centered around Rice, perhaps paired with either second baseman Roc Riggio (No. 8 prospect) or outfielder Everson Pereira (No. 15), could be enough to entice the Pirates. It would give Pittsburgh a couple of high-upside bats to add to their farm system, while the Yankees would get the proven starter they desperately need. It’s a gamble for both teams, a high-stakes poker game where the winner walks away with a crucial piece for their present or future.
So, as the trade deadline looms, the baseball world waits with bated breath. Will Keller remain in Pittsburgh, a beacon of hope for a franchise yearning for relevance? Or will he don the pinstripes and take the mound in the Bronx, tasked with rescuing the Yankees’ season? Only time will tell, but one thing is certain: this trade deadline drama is far from over. The rumor mill is still churning, the whispers are getting louder, and the fate of Mitch Keller hangs in the balance. Stay tuned, folks, the next few days promise to be a wild ride.
On one side of the diamond, we have the chorus of "he’s gotta go" pundits. Bob Nightengale, the USA Today scribe with the ear of the front office gods, recently declared that anyone not named Paul Skenes or Oneil Cruz is on the table in Pittsburgh, and that Keller is "still expected to move." This sentiment echoes throughout the baseball blogosphere, with many analysts viewing Keller as a prime target for contending teams desperate for a rotation boost. After all, a pitcher with Keller’s stuff, coupled with three more years of team control at a reasonable price, is the kind of asset that can make a GM’s phone ring off the hook.
But then, just as the trade winds seem to be blowing Keller out of the Steel City, we have the counter-narrative emerging from the Pirates’ camp. Noah Hiles of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, citing multiple sources, reported that Keller is “likely to stay put.” He points to Pirates GM Ben Cherington's recent emphasis on leadership and performance, suggesting that Keller embodies those qualities and is thus deemed essential to the team's long-term vision. Cherington himself, as quoted by Hiles, stated, “If we’re going to be better in 2026, we need more of that, not less. We would only contemplate giving up something that’s seemingly more proven if we really believe that they give us a better chance to be better by next year.” It’s a classic case of the front office playing coy, keeping their cards close to their vest while subtly inflating their player’s value.
This conflicting information leaves us in a state of delightful uncertainty. Is Cherington genuinely committed to building around Keller? Or is he simply posturing, hoping to drive up the price for his prized pitcher? One thing's for sure: Keller’s name is hotter than a jalapeño right now, and any team looking to bolster their rotation would be foolish not to at least kick the tires.
Enter the New York Yankees, stage left, with their pinstripes slightly rumpled and their playoff hopes teetering on the brink. Their season started with promise, a glimpse of the Bronx Bombers of old. But injuries, particularly to their starting rotation, have taken their toll. The Yankees, currently clinging to a wild card spot like a drowning man to a life raft, are desperate for pitching reinforcements. The loss of Gerrit Cole to Tommy John surgery before the season threw a wrench in their plans, and Clarke Schmidt's similar fate has only compounded the problem. GM Brian Cashman, a man used to pulling off blockbuster trades, now finds himself in a precarious position, needing to shore up his rotation without sacrificing the future.
Keller, with his consistent performance and years of control, seems tailor-made for the Yankees’ needs. ESPN’s Jorge Castillo recently argued that Keller, while not the flashiest name on the trade market, would be a "solid addition to a depleted rotation.” He highlighted Keller’s impressive 3.69 ERA over 127 innings, along with his affordable contract, as key factors that make him an attractive target for the Yankees, who generally prefer acquiring players with multiple years of control. Castillo’s assessment is spot-on: Keller offers the Yankees a proven commodity, a steady hand in a rotation that has been plagued by inconsistency and injury.
But acquiring a pitcher of Keller’s caliber won’t come cheap. The Pirates, even if they are willing to part with him, will demand a significant return. Tim Britton of The Athletic suggests that a package of two young “impact players” might be enough to pry Keller loose, with the Pirates likely prioritizing offensive prospects over pitchers. This brings us to the heart of the Yankees’ dilemma: what are they willing to sacrifice to acquire Keller?
Rumors are swirling that the Yankees are open to including outfielder Spencer Jones, their No. 5 prospect, in a trade package. Jones has been tearing up Triple-A pitching since his recent promotion, showcasing the kind of raw talent that makes scouts drool. However, the Yankees would likely require a king's ransom in return to part with a player of his caliber. Another name that has surfaced is Ben Rice, a promising prospect whose path to the majors might be blocked by Aaron Judge's eventual return to the outfield. With Judge seemingly destined for a permanent DH role, Rice’s value to the Yankees has diminished, making him a more expendable trade chip.
A package centered around Rice, perhaps paired with either second baseman Roc Riggio (No. 8 prospect) or outfielder Everson Pereira (No. 15), could be enough to entice the Pirates. It would give Pittsburgh a couple of high-upside bats to add to their farm system, while the Yankees would get the proven starter they desperately need. It’s a gamble for both teams, a high-stakes poker game where the winner walks away with a crucial piece for their present or future.
So, as the trade deadline looms, the baseball world waits with bated breath. Will Keller remain in Pittsburgh, a beacon of hope for a franchise yearning for relevance? Or will he don the pinstripes and take the mound in the Bronx, tasked with rescuing the Yankees’ season? Only time will tell, but one thing is certain: this trade deadline drama is far from over. The rumor mill is still churning, the whispers are getting louder, and the fate of Mitch Keller hangs in the balance. Stay tuned, folks, the next few days promise to be a wild ride.
Back to news