NYYNEWS Logo

The Splice: Cashman Eyes Duran’s Heat, But at What Cost?

Published on: July 29, 2025
The Bronx Bombers have already made their infield moves, snagging a pair of proven bats in McMahon and Rosario. But the whispers around the dugout, the hushed conversations in the owner's box, they all revolve around one thing: pitching. And not just any pitching, mind you. Brian Cashman, that silver-haired maestro of the trade deadline tango, is reportedly eyeing a flamethrower, a man who can bring the heat when the game hangs in the balance: Jhoan Duran of the Minnesota Twins.

Now, anyone who's seen Duran work knows he’s the real deal. A splicer, as we old-timers might call him, with a fastball that regularly kisses triple digits and a splitter that disappears like a magician's rabbit. This season, he’s been lights out, racking up saves like a kid collecting baseball cards. 6-4, a 2.01 ERA, 16 saves in 18 opportunities – those are numbers that make a manager drool. He’s the kind of arm that can turn a shaky bullpen into a lockdown crew, the kind of guy who can slam the door shut in the ninth and send everyone home happy.

But as any seasoned baseball observer will tell you, acquiring talent of this caliber comes at a price. And in this case, the price tag reportedly includes two of the Yankees’ most promising young arms: Carlos Lagrange and Roc Riggio.

Lagrange, a towering righty who’s been mowing down hitters in Double-A, is the crown jewel of this potential deal. Signed for a song out of the Dominican Republic, he’s blossomed into a legitimate prospect, showcasing a fastball that rivals Duran’s in terms of pure velocity. His 4-2 record and 3.54 ERA in eight starts don't tell the whole story. Look closer, and you’ll see a pitcher with a dominant K-rate, a kid who’s learning how to harness his raw power and turn it into pinpoint precision.

Then there’s Riggio, a scrappy second baseman who’s been tearing it up at the plate. While he might not have the same dazzling stuff as Lagrange, Riggio’s got that intangible “it” factor. He’s a gamer, a kid who plays with a fire in his belly, and his .265 average, 11 home runs, and 28 RBIs in Double-A speak to his offensive potential. He’s projected to arrive in the Bronx sometime next season, adding another potent bat to an already formidable lineup.

So, is this a deal the Yankees should make? It’s a tough call, even for Cashman. On the one hand, Duran would be a game-changer for the bullpen, a missing piece that could propel the Yankees to another World Series run. He gives Boone another late-inning option alongside the mercurial Devin Williams and provides a different look compared to Weaver's rising fastball. Let's not forget, last year’s championship run was fueled by a lights-out bullpen, a group of relievers who posted a microscopic 2.67 postseason ERA. Duran has the potential to be that kind of difference-maker.

But giving up Lagrange and Riggio is a steep price to pay. These aren't just throwaway prospects; they're potential future stars, the kind of players who could anchor the Yankees' rotation and lineup for years to come. Trading them away would represent a significant investment in the present, a gamble that Duran’s impact will outweigh the potential loss of two promising young players.

The Yankees find themselves in a familiar position, a win-now mode that often forces difficult decisions. They currently cling to the top Wild Card spot, a precarious perch in the cutthroat American League. Cashman knows that bolstering the bullpen is crucial to October success. But he also understands the importance of building for the future, of maintaining a pipeline of young talent to ensure sustained success.

The clock is ticking, the trade deadline looms, and Cashman is undoubtedly working the phones, weighing his options, trying to decipher the complex calculus of baseball trades. Is Duran worth the price? Is the allure of a championship enough to justify mortgaging the future? These are the questions that keep a general manager up at night, the questions that will ultimately determine the fate of the Bronx Bombers.

The whispers continue, the rumors swirl, and the baseball world waits with bated breath. Will Cashman pull the trigger on this blockbuster deal? Or will he opt for a different path, a less risky route to bolstering his bullpen? Only time will tell. But one thing is certain: the next few days will be crucial for the Yankees, and the decisions made now could have ramifications for years to come. So stay tuned, folks, because the trade deadline drama is just getting started.
MLB Trade Deadline New York Yankees Minnesota Twins Jhoan Duran
Will the Yankees trade top prospects for Twins closer Jhoan Duran? Brian Cashman weighs the cost of bolstering the bullpen for a World Series run against mortgaging the future.
Felix Pantaleon
Felix Pantaleon
Twitter/X Instagram

Back to news