The Ghost of Pinstripes Past: JT Brubaker and the Yankees' Bullpen Blues
Published on: August 8, 2025
The air in the Bronx is thick with the scent of desperation. It hangs heavy, like the humidity of a late August afternoon, clinging to the pinstripes as the Yankees stumble towards a weekend showdown with the Houston Astros. The latest casualty of this season of unmet expectations? Right-hander JT Brubaker, released into the wild blue yonder of free agency like a misplaced fastball sailing over the outfield wall.
Brubaker’s departure, while not entirely unexpected, adds another layer of melancholy to a season already drowning in it. The Yankees, a team built for October glory, find themselves clawing for relevance in a dogfight of an AL East. The once-vaunted bullpen, supposedly fortified by a flurry of trade deadline acquisitions, continues to resemble a leaky faucet, dripping runs at the most inopportune moments. And now, JT Brubaker, a pitcher who arrived with whispers of potential and departed with a whimper, becomes another footnote in the Yankees’ increasingly convoluted 2025 narrative.
Let's rewind the tape, shall we? Brubaker, a sixth-round pick by the Pirates back in 2015, toiled in the Steel City, showing flashes of brilliance amidst a sea of inconsistency. He battled injuries, including the dreaded Tommy John surgery that cost him the entire 2023 season. The Yankees, ever the gamblers, saw something they liked in the then-30-year-old, acquiring him in the spring of 2024 for infield prospect Keiner Delgado and some international bonus pool money. It was a classic Cashman maneuver: a low-risk, high-reward gamble on a pitcher with the potential to blossom in the right environment.
Unfortunately for Brubaker, and for the Yankees, the Bronx proved to be anything but the right environment. A fractured rib suffered in spring training delayed his pinstriped debut until late June. When he finally took the mound, he displayed glimpses of the groundball-inducing, strikeout-generating pitcher the Yankees hoped he could be. In 16 innings across 12 appearances, he posted a respectable 3.38 ERA and a 1.19 WHIP, his best stretch of big-league ball since breaking into the majors with Pittsburgh.
But the devil, as they say, is in the details. While the surface numbers hinted at effectiveness, a deeper dive revealed some troubling trends. Brubaker’s strikeout rate was a paltry 15.9%, well below league average. His walk rate, a hefty 14.3%, was equally alarming. He was, in essence, a tightrope walker without a net, relying on a 44.2% groundball rate to escape the jams he frequently created. In a high-stakes environment like Yankee Stadium, such a strategy is akin to playing Russian roulette with a fully loaded revolver.
The Yankees, desperate to plug the holes in their sinking ship, went all-in at the trade deadline. They snagged All-Star closer David Bednar from the Pirates, bolstering the back end of the bullpen. They added Jake Bird from the Rockies and Camilo Doval from the Giants, further strengthening their relief corps. These moves, heralded as potential game-changers, were supposed to solidify a bullpen that had been a season-long source of frustration.
But the script, as it so often does in the Bronx, refused to cooperate. Since the deadline, the Yankees have dropped five of six, including an embarrassing sweep at the hands of the lowly Marlins – a first in franchise history. Devin Williams, the prized bullpen acquisition from the previous offseason, has looked like a shell of his former self, sporting an unsightly 5.44 ERA. Luke Weaver, returning from a hamstring injury, has yet to find his rhythm. The bullpen, despite the influx of talent, remains a liability.
And so, JT Brubaker, caught in the undertow of the Yankees’ struggles, becomes the latest victim of their desperate search for answers. He’s a casualty of circumstance, a pitcher who simply couldn’t find his footing in the pressure cooker of the Bronx. His release, while seemingly insignificant in the grand scheme of things, is symbolic of the Yankees’ season: a story of unfulfilled potential, dashed hopes, and a constant shuffling of the deck chairs as the Titanic slowly takes on water.
Now, the Yankees stare down the barrel of a crucial series against the Astros, a team that has become their perennial nemesis. They’ll do so without JT Brubaker, a pitcher whose brief tenure in pinstripes will likely be remembered more for its brevity than its impact. The Yankees will continue their search for the right combination of arms, hoping to find the magic formula that can transform their beleaguered bullpen into a weapon. But as the calendar flips towards September, and the playoffs loom on the horizon, the question remains: can the Yankees find their way back to October, or will this season be remembered as another ghost of pinstripes past?
Brubaker’s departure, while not entirely unexpected, adds another layer of melancholy to a season already drowning in it. The Yankees, a team built for October glory, find themselves clawing for relevance in a dogfight of an AL East. The once-vaunted bullpen, supposedly fortified by a flurry of trade deadline acquisitions, continues to resemble a leaky faucet, dripping runs at the most inopportune moments. And now, JT Brubaker, a pitcher who arrived with whispers of potential and departed with a whimper, becomes another footnote in the Yankees’ increasingly convoluted 2025 narrative.
Let's rewind the tape, shall we? Brubaker, a sixth-round pick by the Pirates back in 2015, toiled in the Steel City, showing flashes of brilliance amidst a sea of inconsistency. He battled injuries, including the dreaded Tommy John surgery that cost him the entire 2023 season. The Yankees, ever the gamblers, saw something they liked in the then-30-year-old, acquiring him in the spring of 2024 for infield prospect Keiner Delgado and some international bonus pool money. It was a classic Cashman maneuver: a low-risk, high-reward gamble on a pitcher with the potential to blossom in the right environment.
Unfortunately for Brubaker, and for the Yankees, the Bronx proved to be anything but the right environment. A fractured rib suffered in spring training delayed his pinstriped debut until late June. When he finally took the mound, he displayed glimpses of the groundball-inducing, strikeout-generating pitcher the Yankees hoped he could be. In 16 innings across 12 appearances, he posted a respectable 3.38 ERA and a 1.19 WHIP, his best stretch of big-league ball since breaking into the majors with Pittsburgh.
But the devil, as they say, is in the details. While the surface numbers hinted at effectiveness, a deeper dive revealed some troubling trends. Brubaker’s strikeout rate was a paltry 15.9%, well below league average. His walk rate, a hefty 14.3%, was equally alarming. He was, in essence, a tightrope walker without a net, relying on a 44.2% groundball rate to escape the jams he frequently created. In a high-stakes environment like Yankee Stadium, such a strategy is akin to playing Russian roulette with a fully loaded revolver.
The Yankees, desperate to plug the holes in their sinking ship, went all-in at the trade deadline. They snagged All-Star closer David Bednar from the Pirates, bolstering the back end of the bullpen. They added Jake Bird from the Rockies and Camilo Doval from the Giants, further strengthening their relief corps. These moves, heralded as potential game-changers, were supposed to solidify a bullpen that had been a season-long source of frustration.
But the script, as it so often does in the Bronx, refused to cooperate. Since the deadline, the Yankees have dropped five of six, including an embarrassing sweep at the hands of the lowly Marlins – a first in franchise history. Devin Williams, the prized bullpen acquisition from the previous offseason, has looked like a shell of his former self, sporting an unsightly 5.44 ERA. Luke Weaver, returning from a hamstring injury, has yet to find his rhythm. The bullpen, despite the influx of talent, remains a liability.
And so, JT Brubaker, caught in the undertow of the Yankees’ struggles, becomes the latest victim of their desperate search for answers. He’s a casualty of circumstance, a pitcher who simply couldn’t find his footing in the pressure cooker of the Bronx. His release, while seemingly insignificant in the grand scheme of things, is symbolic of the Yankees’ season: a story of unfulfilled potential, dashed hopes, and a constant shuffling of the deck chairs as the Titanic slowly takes on water.
Now, the Yankees stare down the barrel of a crucial series against the Astros, a team that has become their perennial nemesis. They’ll do so without JT Brubaker, a pitcher whose brief tenure in pinstripes will likely be remembered more for its brevity than its impact. The Yankees will continue their search for the right combination of arms, hoping to find the magic formula that can transform their beleaguered bullpen into a weapon. But as the calendar flips towards September, and the playoffs loom on the horizon, the question remains: can the Yankees find their way back to October, or will this season be remembered as another ghost of pinstripes past?
Back to news