Weaver's Wasteland: A Bronx Bombing of the Wrong Kind
Published on: September 16, 2025
The echoes of Aaron Judge's thunderous bat, recently crowned AL Player of the Week, still reverberated around the Bronx. His five home runs and near-mythical 1.760 OPS the previous week had Yankee fans dreaming of October glory. But Monday night, those dreams curdled like day-old milk under the harsh fluorescent lights of reality. The Minnesota Twins, often the Yankees’ punching bag, flipped the script, silencing the Bronx Bombers and leaving the pinstriped faithful with a bitter taste in their mouths. And no one felt that bitterness more acutely than Luke Weaver.
The game started promisingly enough. Simeon Woods Richardson, the young Twins hurler, was dealing, racking up strikeouts like a supermarket cashier scanning groceries on double-coupon day. Eleven Ks in six innings, a performance that would normally spell doom for the opposition. But Carlos Rodon, the Yankees' stoic southpaw, matched him pitch for pitch, keeping the game within reach. A 2-0 deficit as the game entered the seventh inning? A manageable hill to climb for a team boasting the firepower of the Yankees. Then came Luke Weaver. And then came the deluge.
“Yeah. That was trash,” Weaver confessed to reporters after the game, his words raw and unfiltered. He didn’t mince words, didn’t offer excuses. He simply laid bare the brutal truth of his performance. It was an assessment as stark as the 7-0 scoreline that glared from the scoreboard.
The normally reliable Weaver, a veteran presence in the Yankees’ bullpen, looked utterly lost on the mound. His mechanics were a mess, his pitches arriving late and hanging tantalizingly over the plate. The Twins, sensing blood in the water, pounced. Three doubles. Two walks. Five runs. All before Weaver could record a single out. The inning unfolded with the agonizing slowness of a car crash in slow motion, each hit a fresh wound, each run another nail in the coffin of the Yankees' hopes.
“The body just wasn’t on time,” Weaver explained, his voice laced with frustration. “It wasn’t aligned with what I was trying to execute and do. Felt like I was fighting myself the whole time. Mentally, just trying to overcome it and have a good mindset and stay within myself. Those two things weren’t coming together.”
His words painted a vivid picture of a pitcher at war with himself. The mental game, so crucial to success at the highest level, had deserted him. The physical execution, honed over years of practice and competition, had abandoned him. The result was a performance that could only be described, in Weaver's own words, as “trash.”
This wasn't the Luke Weaver Yankee fans had come to rely on. Just last season, he had been a bedrock of the bullpen, a reliable arm that manager Aaron Boone could turn to in high-leverage situations. He had started 2025 in similarly dominant fashion, posting a minuscule 1.05 ERA through his first 24 appearances. He was, in short, the anti-trash.
Then came the hamstring injury in June, an 18-game absence that seemed to disrupt the delicate balance of Weaver's game. Since returning from the IL, he had been a shadow of his former self. His ERA had ballooned to 6.21, his WHIP a bloated 1.359. And in September, with the Yankees fighting for their playoff lives, his struggles had intensified. A ghastly 28.13 ERA and a WHIP approaching 5.00 painted a picture of a pitcher in freefall.
The Yankees, a team built on power and pitching, have found themselves unexpectedly vulnerable in the latter department. The bullpen, once a source of strength, has become a recurring nightmare. While the team publicly maintains a confident facade, the cracks are beginning to show. The whispers of doubt are growing louder. Can they really make a deep playoff run with a bullpen this volatile? Can they rely on Weaver, once a trusted fireman, to extinguish the flames when the heat is on?
Monday night’s loss to the Twins dropped the Yankees five games behind the Toronto Blue Jays in the AL East, a gap that feels as wide as the Grand Canyon. They cling precariously to a one-game lead over the Boston Red Sox for the top Wild Card spot, a position that offers little comfort in the cutthroat world of October baseball.
The Yankees, a team accustomed to playing the role of hunter, suddenly find themselves the hunted. Their margin for error has shrunk to the size of the strike zone. And every implosion from the bullpen, every performance like Weaver’s on Monday night, pushes them closer to the precipice.
The season, like a late-inning game, hangs in the balance. The Yankees, once seemingly invincible, now look vulnerable. And the question that hangs heavy in the Bronx air is this: can they find a way to clean up the mess, to salvage the season, before it ends up in the dumpster fire of disappointment? The answer, like so much in baseball, remains elusive, hidden in the unpredictable drama of the games yet to be played.
The game started promisingly enough. Simeon Woods Richardson, the young Twins hurler, was dealing, racking up strikeouts like a supermarket cashier scanning groceries on double-coupon day. Eleven Ks in six innings, a performance that would normally spell doom for the opposition. But Carlos Rodon, the Yankees' stoic southpaw, matched him pitch for pitch, keeping the game within reach. A 2-0 deficit as the game entered the seventh inning? A manageable hill to climb for a team boasting the firepower of the Yankees. Then came Luke Weaver. And then came the deluge.
“Yeah. That was trash,” Weaver confessed to reporters after the game, his words raw and unfiltered. He didn’t mince words, didn’t offer excuses. He simply laid bare the brutal truth of his performance. It was an assessment as stark as the 7-0 scoreline that glared from the scoreboard.
The normally reliable Weaver, a veteran presence in the Yankees’ bullpen, looked utterly lost on the mound. His mechanics were a mess, his pitches arriving late and hanging tantalizingly over the plate. The Twins, sensing blood in the water, pounced. Three doubles. Two walks. Five runs. All before Weaver could record a single out. The inning unfolded with the agonizing slowness of a car crash in slow motion, each hit a fresh wound, each run another nail in the coffin of the Yankees' hopes.
“The body just wasn’t on time,” Weaver explained, his voice laced with frustration. “It wasn’t aligned with what I was trying to execute and do. Felt like I was fighting myself the whole time. Mentally, just trying to overcome it and have a good mindset and stay within myself. Those two things weren’t coming together.”
His words painted a vivid picture of a pitcher at war with himself. The mental game, so crucial to success at the highest level, had deserted him. The physical execution, honed over years of practice and competition, had abandoned him. The result was a performance that could only be described, in Weaver's own words, as “trash.”
This wasn't the Luke Weaver Yankee fans had come to rely on. Just last season, he had been a bedrock of the bullpen, a reliable arm that manager Aaron Boone could turn to in high-leverage situations. He had started 2025 in similarly dominant fashion, posting a minuscule 1.05 ERA through his first 24 appearances. He was, in short, the anti-trash.
Then came the hamstring injury in June, an 18-game absence that seemed to disrupt the delicate balance of Weaver's game. Since returning from the IL, he had been a shadow of his former self. His ERA had ballooned to 6.21, his WHIP a bloated 1.359. And in September, with the Yankees fighting for their playoff lives, his struggles had intensified. A ghastly 28.13 ERA and a WHIP approaching 5.00 painted a picture of a pitcher in freefall.
The Yankees, a team built on power and pitching, have found themselves unexpectedly vulnerable in the latter department. The bullpen, once a source of strength, has become a recurring nightmare. While the team publicly maintains a confident facade, the cracks are beginning to show. The whispers of doubt are growing louder. Can they really make a deep playoff run with a bullpen this volatile? Can they rely on Weaver, once a trusted fireman, to extinguish the flames when the heat is on?
Monday night’s loss to the Twins dropped the Yankees five games behind the Toronto Blue Jays in the AL East, a gap that feels as wide as the Grand Canyon. They cling precariously to a one-game lead over the Boston Red Sox for the top Wild Card spot, a position that offers little comfort in the cutthroat world of October baseball.
The Yankees, a team accustomed to playing the role of hunter, suddenly find themselves the hunted. Their margin for error has shrunk to the size of the strike zone. And every implosion from the bullpen, every performance like Weaver’s on Monday night, pushes them closer to the precipice.
The season, like a late-inning game, hangs in the balance. The Yankees, once seemingly invincible, now look vulnerable. And the question that hangs heavy in the Bronx air is this: can they find a way to clean up the mess, to salvage the season, before it ends up in the dumpster fire of disappointment? The answer, like so much in baseball, remains elusive, hidden in the unpredictable drama of the games yet to be played.
Back to news