The Air Raid Siren is Broken: Devin Williams and the Yankees’ Bullpen Rebuild
Published on: August 3, 2025
The Bronx buzzed with anticipation last winter. The Yankees, perennial contenders perpetually searching for that elusive 28th World Series title, had landed a prize: Devin Williams, the fire-balling closer from Milwaukee, owner of a devastating changeup and a swagger that screamed “shutdown inning.” He was the missing piece, the final ingredient in a championship-caliber bullpen. Now, as summer fades into autumn, that siren song of October glory rings hollow. Williams, sporting a bloated 5.01 ERA, finds himself adrift in pinstripes, a symbol of the Yankees’ evolving bullpen landscape and perhaps, a cautionary tale of the fleeting nature of baseball success.
Let's rewind to 2022. Williams, a two-time All-Star, was lights-out for the Brewers, racking up saves with the efficiency of a seasoned assembly line. He was the type of arm that could shorten games, turning nine innings into seven, providing a bridge from the starting rotation to victory. The Yankees, eager to bolster their late-inning options, saw Williams as the answer to their prayers. The trade, executed with the precision of a Brian Cashman masterclass, was hailed as a coup.
Fast forward to the present, and the narrative has taken a decidedly different turn. Williams’ 2024 season began with a frustrating four-month absence due to a stress fracture in his back. The injury, a cruel twist of fate, disrupted his rhythm and set the stage for a season of struggles. Upon his return, the Williams of old was nowhere to be found. The changeup, once his calling card, lost its bite, hanging tantalizingly over the plate, begging to be crushed. The fastball, though still possessing its signature velocity, lacked the pinpoint command that made him so effective. The results, as evidenced by his unsightly ERA, speak for themselves.
The Yankees, never a team to stand pat in the face of adversity, reacted decisively. The trade deadline became their playground, as they orchestrated a series of moves that reshaped their bullpen. Enter David Bednar, the steely-eyed veteran with a track record of high-leverage success. Then came Jake Bird, a versatile arm capable of navigating multiple innings. And finally, the coup de grâce: Camilo Doval, another flame-throwing closer with a penchant for striking fear into the hearts of opposing hitters. These acquisitions, each representing a significant investment in the team's future, sent a clear message: the Yankees are building a bullpen built for October, and Williams, at least in his current form, might not be part of the blueprint.
The arrival of Bednar and Doval, in particular, has cast a long shadow over Williams' future in the Bronx. Both pitchers boast closing experience and possess the kind of consistent performance the Yankees crave. Their presence creates a logjam at the back end of the bullpen, a competition for innings that Williams, with his current struggles, seems unlikely to win.
The situation is further complicated by the recent contract signed by Tanner Scott, the Dodgers' newly acquired reliever. Scott's four-year, $72 million deal sets a new benchmark for high-end bullpen arms, a price tag the Yankees are unlikely to match for a pitcher with Williams' current performance and injury history.
While Williams remains under contract for the remainder of the season, the writing seems to be on the wall. His free agency looms, and the Yankees, armed with a revamped bullpen and facing financial constraints, appear poised to move on.
This isn’t to say that Williams’ career is over. He’s still young, still possesses the raw talent that made him one of the game's most feared closers. A change of scenery, a fresh start with a new organization, might be just what he needs to rediscover his form. But his time in pinstripes, once brimming with promise, now feels like a fading memory.
The Yankees' bullpen, once a source of anxiety, has undergone a dramatic transformation. The additions of Bednar, Bird, and Doval have injected a sense of stability and depth, creating a formidable late-inning force. But the story of Devin Williams, the fallen star, serves as a reminder of the capricious nature of baseball. Performance can fluctuate, fortunes can change, and even the most promising acquisitions can fall short of expectations. The Yankees, ever focused on the ultimate prize, have moved on, leaving Williams to ponder what might have been and to search for a new chapter in his baseball journey. The air raid siren, once poised to herald the arrival of a dominant closer, remains silent, a testament to the unpredictable nature of the game and the ever-evolving landscape of the Yankees’ bullpen.
Let's rewind to 2022. Williams, a two-time All-Star, was lights-out for the Brewers, racking up saves with the efficiency of a seasoned assembly line. He was the type of arm that could shorten games, turning nine innings into seven, providing a bridge from the starting rotation to victory. The Yankees, eager to bolster their late-inning options, saw Williams as the answer to their prayers. The trade, executed with the precision of a Brian Cashman masterclass, was hailed as a coup.
Fast forward to the present, and the narrative has taken a decidedly different turn. Williams’ 2024 season began with a frustrating four-month absence due to a stress fracture in his back. The injury, a cruel twist of fate, disrupted his rhythm and set the stage for a season of struggles. Upon his return, the Williams of old was nowhere to be found. The changeup, once his calling card, lost its bite, hanging tantalizingly over the plate, begging to be crushed. The fastball, though still possessing its signature velocity, lacked the pinpoint command that made him so effective. The results, as evidenced by his unsightly ERA, speak for themselves.
The Yankees, never a team to stand pat in the face of adversity, reacted decisively. The trade deadline became their playground, as they orchestrated a series of moves that reshaped their bullpen. Enter David Bednar, the steely-eyed veteran with a track record of high-leverage success. Then came Jake Bird, a versatile arm capable of navigating multiple innings. And finally, the coup de grâce: Camilo Doval, another flame-throwing closer with a penchant for striking fear into the hearts of opposing hitters. These acquisitions, each representing a significant investment in the team's future, sent a clear message: the Yankees are building a bullpen built for October, and Williams, at least in his current form, might not be part of the blueprint.
The arrival of Bednar and Doval, in particular, has cast a long shadow over Williams' future in the Bronx. Both pitchers boast closing experience and possess the kind of consistent performance the Yankees crave. Their presence creates a logjam at the back end of the bullpen, a competition for innings that Williams, with his current struggles, seems unlikely to win.
The situation is further complicated by the recent contract signed by Tanner Scott, the Dodgers' newly acquired reliever. Scott's four-year, $72 million deal sets a new benchmark for high-end bullpen arms, a price tag the Yankees are unlikely to match for a pitcher with Williams' current performance and injury history.
While Williams remains under contract for the remainder of the season, the writing seems to be on the wall. His free agency looms, and the Yankees, armed with a revamped bullpen and facing financial constraints, appear poised to move on.
This isn’t to say that Williams’ career is over. He’s still young, still possesses the raw talent that made him one of the game's most feared closers. A change of scenery, a fresh start with a new organization, might be just what he needs to rediscover his form. But his time in pinstripes, once brimming with promise, now feels like a fading memory.
The Yankees' bullpen, once a source of anxiety, has undergone a dramatic transformation. The additions of Bednar, Bird, and Doval have injected a sense of stability and depth, creating a formidable late-inning force. But the story of Devin Williams, the fallen star, serves as a reminder of the capricious nature of baseball. Performance can fluctuate, fortunes can change, and even the most promising acquisitions can fall short of expectations. The Yankees, ever focused on the ultimate prize, have moved on, leaving Williams to ponder what might have been and to search for a new chapter in his baseball journey. The air raid siren, once poised to herald the arrival of a dominant closer, remains silent, a testament to the unpredictable nature of the game and the ever-evolving landscape of the Yankees’ bullpen.
Back to news