The Judge's Gavel: 600 Homers and a Verdict on History
Published on: September 13, 2025
The crack of the bat echoed through Fenway, a familiar sound carrying a historic weight. Aaron Judge, the Yankees' captain, had just launched his 362nd career home run, a missile that sailed over the Green Monster and landed him squarely in the pantheon of pinstriped power. He’d just eclipsed Joe DiMaggio, leaving only the hallowed trinity of Ruth, Mantle, and Gehrig ahead of him on the Yankees' all-time home run list. But Judge’s ascent isn’t just about climbing the ranks; it's about rewriting the rules of power hitting in a modern game that seems determined to suppress it.
Think about it: Ruth and Mantle, titans of their time, swung their way to legendary status against pitchers who rarely flirted with 95 mph. Gehrig, the Iron Horse, churned out hits and homers with metronomic consistency, a run-producing machine in a simpler era. DiMaggio, with his effortless grace, and Berra, the squat powerhouse, completed a Yankees dynasty that made October baseball feel like a birthright. Judge now sits at their table, having earned his place with a ferocity and efficiency that feels almost anachronistic.
The numbers tell a compelling tale. Judge's career average of 52 home runs per 162 games puts him in the rarefied air occupied by only one other Yankee: the Babe himself. His home-run-per-plate-appearance rate of 0.09 is a dead heat with Ruth for the most lethal long-ball clip in Yankees history. Through ten seasons, Judge boasts a .292 batting average, a .411 on-base percentage, and a slugging percentage that would make even the Sultan of Swat blush at .613. And his OPS+ of 177 screams what every opposing pitcher already knows: this man is 77 percent better than the average hitter, and he's been doing it for a decade.
But context is king in baseball, and Judge's context is starkly different from the legends he’s chasing. Mantle’s 536 homers came in an era when pitchers relied on guile and movement, rarely touching the high heat that's now commonplace. Judge, on the other hand, steps into the box against a generation of flamethrowers sculpted in the weight room and armed with cutting-edge analytics. League-average fastball velocity now sits comfortably above 94 mph, with relievers routinely dialing it up to 98 and beyond. Factor in the devilish deception of data-driven pitch design – sliders tunneling off high heaters, splitters masquerading as changeups – and Judge’s power surge becomes even more extraordinary. He's not just hitting home runs; he's conquering a scientific assault on the long ball.
So, the question becomes: how many more will he hit?
At 33, with six years remaining on the nine-year pact he signed before the 2023 season, Judge already has 362 dingers under his belt. He owns the single-season franchise record of 62, set in a 2022 campaign that felt like a nightly fireworks display, and followed it up with a blistering 58 in 2024. Even with the inevitable dips and valleys of a long season, his recent output – 47 homers in 137 games in 2025 – offers compelling evidence that he's nowhere near slowing down. His career average of nearly 52 homers per 162 games speaks for itself.
However, projecting future performance requires a dose of pragmatic caution. Power may age gracefully, but durability often doesn't. Judge has battled his share of injuries, losing significant chunks of the 2018, 2019, and 2023 seasons to oblique, rib, and toe ailments. Yet, his resilience shines through. His last two healthy campaigns, 2024 and 2025, demonstrate his continued ability to carry the Yankees’ offensive load.
Let’s play with the numbers. If Judge averages a robust 45 home runs per year over the next six seasons, he’ll tack on another 270 to his total, propelling him to a staggering 632. That would vault him past both Mantle (536) and Gehrig (493), leaving only the Bambino (714) ahead of him in the annals of Yankees history. Even with a more conservative estimate of 40 homers per year, he’d still finish around the 600 mark, an exclusive club currently occupied by only nine players in the history of Major League Baseball.
The wild card, as always, is health. If Judge can manage to stay on the field for 140 games or more in most of his remaining seasons, the pursuit of Ruth becomes tantalizingly realistic. Even if age and injury inevitably take their toll, requiring him to adjust his approach and perhaps sacrifice some power for longevity, the Yankees captain is on a trajectory to solidify his place as the franchise’s most prolific slugger since the Mantle era.
But there’s another dimension to Judge's legacy, one that separates him from the legends he's chasing: October glory. Nine of the top ten Yankees in Wins Above Replacement (WAR) have World Series rings. Judge does not. His lone appearance on the Fall Classic stage ended in disappointment against the Dodgers. Until he hoists that coveted trophy, comparisons to Ruth or Mantle will always carry an asterisk, a silent acknowledgment of unfinished business.
Still, every time Judge digs into the batter's box, he strengthens his case. In this high-velocity era, dominated by specialized relievers armed with an arsenal of unhittable pitches, his dominance feels even more remarkable. If the projections hold true, by the time his contract expires, he won’t just be remembered as the face of the 2020s Yankees. He’ll be recognized as a player who forced his way into a conversation reserved for baseball's immortals, a slugger who defied the odds and reshaped the narrative of power in the modern game. The Judge’s gavel will come down hard, delivering a verdict on history that resonates far beyond the Bronx.
Think about it: Ruth and Mantle, titans of their time, swung their way to legendary status against pitchers who rarely flirted with 95 mph. Gehrig, the Iron Horse, churned out hits and homers with metronomic consistency, a run-producing machine in a simpler era. DiMaggio, with his effortless grace, and Berra, the squat powerhouse, completed a Yankees dynasty that made October baseball feel like a birthright. Judge now sits at their table, having earned his place with a ferocity and efficiency that feels almost anachronistic.
The numbers tell a compelling tale. Judge's career average of 52 home runs per 162 games puts him in the rarefied air occupied by only one other Yankee: the Babe himself. His home-run-per-plate-appearance rate of 0.09 is a dead heat with Ruth for the most lethal long-ball clip in Yankees history. Through ten seasons, Judge boasts a .292 batting average, a .411 on-base percentage, and a slugging percentage that would make even the Sultan of Swat blush at .613. And his OPS+ of 177 screams what every opposing pitcher already knows: this man is 77 percent better than the average hitter, and he's been doing it for a decade.
But context is king in baseball, and Judge's context is starkly different from the legends he’s chasing. Mantle’s 536 homers came in an era when pitchers relied on guile and movement, rarely touching the high heat that's now commonplace. Judge, on the other hand, steps into the box against a generation of flamethrowers sculpted in the weight room and armed with cutting-edge analytics. League-average fastball velocity now sits comfortably above 94 mph, with relievers routinely dialing it up to 98 and beyond. Factor in the devilish deception of data-driven pitch design – sliders tunneling off high heaters, splitters masquerading as changeups – and Judge’s power surge becomes even more extraordinary. He's not just hitting home runs; he's conquering a scientific assault on the long ball.
So, the question becomes: how many more will he hit?
At 33, with six years remaining on the nine-year pact he signed before the 2023 season, Judge already has 362 dingers under his belt. He owns the single-season franchise record of 62, set in a 2022 campaign that felt like a nightly fireworks display, and followed it up with a blistering 58 in 2024. Even with the inevitable dips and valleys of a long season, his recent output – 47 homers in 137 games in 2025 – offers compelling evidence that he's nowhere near slowing down. His career average of nearly 52 homers per 162 games speaks for itself.
However, projecting future performance requires a dose of pragmatic caution. Power may age gracefully, but durability often doesn't. Judge has battled his share of injuries, losing significant chunks of the 2018, 2019, and 2023 seasons to oblique, rib, and toe ailments. Yet, his resilience shines through. His last two healthy campaigns, 2024 and 2025, demonstrate his continued ability to carry the Yankees’ offensive load.
Let’s play with the numbers. If Judge averages a robust 45 home runs per year over the next six seasons, he’ll tack on another 270 to his total, propelling him to a staggering 632. That would vault him past both Mantle (536) and Gehrig (493), leaving only the Bambino (714) ahead of him in the annals of Yankees history. Even with a more conservative estimate of 40 homers per year, he’d still finish around the 600 mark, an exclusive club currently occupied by only nine players in the history of Major League Baseball.
The wild card, as always, is health. If Judge can manage to stay on the field for 140 games or more in most of his remaining seasons, the pursuit of Ruth becomes tantalizingly realistic. Even if age and injury inevitably take their toll, requiring him to adjust his approach and perhaps sacrifice some power for longevity, the Yankees captain is on a trajectory to solidify his place as the franchise’s most prolific slugger since the Mantle era.
But there’s another dimension to Judge's legacy, one that separates him from the legends he's chasing: October glory. Nine of the top ten Yankees in Wins Above Replacement (WAR) have World Series rings. Judge does not. His lone appearance on the Fall Classic stage ended in disappointment against the Dodgers. Until he hoists that coveted trophy, comparisons to Ruth or Mantle will always carry an asterisk, a silent acknowledgment of unfinished business.
Still, every time Judge digs into the batter's box, he strengthens his case. In this high-velocity era, dominated by specialized relievers armed with an arsenal of unhittable pitches, his dominance feels even more remarkable. If the projections hold true, by the time his contract expires, he won’t just be remembered as the face of the 2020s Yankees. He’ll be recognized as a player who forced his way into a conversation reserved for baseball's immortals, a slugger who defied the odds and reshaped the narrative of power in the modern game. The Judge’s gavel will come down hard, delivering a verdict on history that resonates far beyond the Bronx.
Back to news